BAILII [Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback]

European Court of Human Rights


You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> European Court of Human Rights >> KABARDOKOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA - 11421/13 (Judgment : Violation of Right to a fair trial - Civil proceedings - Access to court Fair hearing) [2017] ECHR 971 (07 November 2017)
URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2017/971.html
Cite as: ECLI:CE:ECHR:2017:1107JUD001142113, [2017] ECHR 971, CE:ECHR:2017:1107JUD001142113

[New search] [Contents list] [Context] [View without highlighting] [Printable RTF version] [Help]


     

     

     

    THIRD SECTION

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    CASE OF KABARDOKOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA

     

    (Applications nos. 11421/13 and 22 others - see appended list)

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    JUDGMENT

     

     

    STRASBOURG

     

    7 November 2017

     

     

     

     

     

    This judgment is final but it may be subject to editorial revision.

     


     

    In the case of Kabardokov and Others v. Russia,

    The European Court of Human Rights (Third Section), sitting as a Committee composed of:

              Luis López Guerra, President,
              Dmitry Dedov,
              Jolien Schukking, judges,
    and Fatoş Aracı, Deputy Section Registrar,

    Having deliberated in private on 10 October 2017,

    Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date:

    PROCEDURE

    1.  The case originated in 23 applications (nos. 11421/13, 15459/13, 15625/13, 15651/13, 18295/13, 19142/13, 19156/13, 19161/13, 19398/13, 19408/13, 19549/13, 19687/13, 19697/13, 19722/13, 22925/13, 22935/13, 22953/13, 23006/13, 23109/13, 23135/13, 23145/13, 26466/13 and 58066/13) against the Russian Federation lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by one hundred sixty-three Russian nationals. The applicants’ details appear in the Appendix.

    2.  The Russian Government (“the Government”) were represented initially by Mr G. Matyushkin, the Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights, and then by his successor in that office, Mr M. Galperin.

    3.  On 27 August and 28 August 2014 the applications were communicated to the Government.

    THE FACTS

    I.  THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE

    4.  Between 1986 and 1987 the applicants took part in the clean-up operation at the Chernobyl nuclear disaster site. They were subsequently registered disabled and became entitled to various social benefits and compensation paid on a regular basis.

    5.  Considering these benefits insufficient, the applicants together with other 482 people, sued the Russian Ministry of Finance for additional compensation corresponding to non-pecuniary damage suffered as a result of their participation in the operation.

    6.  On different dates in January and April 2011 the Nalchik Town Court of Kabardino-Balkaria (“the Town Court”) allowed their claims in part and awarded each claimant, including the applicants, compensation ranging between 1,100,000 Russian roubles (RUB) and RUB 1,800,000 for non-pecuniary damage.

    7.  No appeals were lodged against these judgments within the statutory ten-day time-limit. The judgments became final. Some judgments in respect of several applicants remained unenforced (see “Enforcement status” in the Appendix).

    8.  On different dates in 2012 and 2013 the domestic courts granted the defendant authority’s request to extend the time-limit for appeal essentially on the ground that the defendant authority had not been served with the impugned judgments. Subsequently the regional Supreme Court quashed the judgments delivered in the applicants’ favour on the grounds that they had been based on retrospective application of the law. The applicants were ordered to repay the sums received under the judgments.

    9.  The applicants lodged a supervisory review application. There is no indication that they requested the enforcement proceedings to be suspended pending the examination of their supervisory review application.

    10.  Between June and August 2013 the Presidium of the regional Supreme Court partially quashed the appeal judgments as regards the applicants’ obligation to reimburse the sums paid.

    II.  RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW

    11.  The relevant domestic law and practice governing the restoration of the time-limits for appeal is summed up in the Court’s judgment in the case of Magomedov and Others v. Russia (nos. 33636/09 and 9 others, §§ 35-43, 28 March 2017).

    THE LAW

    I.  JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS

    12.  In accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of the Court, the Court decides to consider the applications in a single judgment, given their similar factual and legal background (see Kazakevich and 9 other “Army Pensioners” cases v. Russia, nos. 14290/03 and 9 others, § 15, 14 January 2010).

    II.  STRIKING PARTS OF THE APPLICATIONS OUT OF THE LIST OF CASES

    13.  The Court notes that in their submissions of various dates in 2015 some of the applicants’ representatives informed the Court that the applicants either did not intend to pursue their applications before the Court, or that they failed to maintain contact with the representatives concerning the proceedings before the Court.

    14.  Article 37 § 1 of the Convention, in its relevant part, reads:

    “1.  The Court may at any stage of the proceedings decide to strike an application out of its list of cases where the circumstances lead to the conclusion that

    (a)  the applicant does not intend to pursue his application; or ...

    ...

    (c)  ... it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the application ...”

    15.  On different dates indicated in the appendix (see ”Strike out warnings” in the Appendix) the applicants were notified that the period allowed for submission of their comments and just satisfaction claims had expired and that no extension of time had been requested. The applicants’ attention was drawn to Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention, which provides that the Court may strike a case out of its list of cases where the circumstances lead to the conclusion that the applicant does not intend to pursue the application.

    16.  No response has been received from the applicants, who have not contacted the Court ever since.

    17.  The Court considers that, in these circumstances, the applicants may be regarded as no longer wishing to pursue their applications, within the meaning of Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention. Furthermore, in accordance with Article 37 § 1 in fine, the Court finds no special circumstances regarding respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols which require the continued examination of the applications.

    18.  In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the applications in respect of the applicants indicated in the appendix (see “Strike out” in the Appendix) out of the list.

    III.  LOCUS STANDI AS REGARDS THE APPLICATIONS Nos. 15651/13, 19156/13, 19408/13, 19687/13, 19722/13 AND 23006/13

    19.  The Court notes that Ms M. Arkhipova, Ms O. Lopatina, Ms M. Kazbekova, Ms Z. Nastuyeva, Ms L. Neyevina, Ms L. Finogenova, Ms R. Shiklyasheva, and Ms M. Yermolova expressed a wish to continue proceedings in respect of their deceased relatives.

    A.  The parties’ submissions

    20.  With reference to the case of Belskiy v. Russia ((dec.), no. 23593/03, 26 November 2009) the Government submitted that the relatives of the deceased applicants had neither been involved in the domestic proceedings either before or after the applicants’ death nor applied for legal succession in those proceedings. The award in the applicants’ favour was made by the domestic courts in respect of compensation for health damage which under the domestic law was of personal non-transferrable nature and did not provide for legal succession of the right to compensation. Therefore, the applicants’ relatives did not inherit the right to claim the judgment debt. Furthermore, in respect of some of the applicants the judgments had been annulled and thus no compensation debt existed at the moment of the applicants’ death. Therefore, the relevant applications should be struck out of the Court’s list of cases pursuant to Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention.

    21.  The applicants did not comment on the Government’s submission.

    B.  The Court’s assessment

    22.  As to Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention, the Court notes that it has previously recognised the right of the relatives of the deceased applicants to pursue the application concerning social payments due to their close relatives but not received in their lifetimes (see Streltsov and other “Novocherkassk military pensioners” cases v. Russia, nos. 8549/06 and 86 others, § 37, 29 July 2010, and Nosov and Others v. Russia, nos. 9117/04 and 10441/04, §§ 29-30, 20 February 2014). However, unlike the Streltsov and other “Novocherkassk military pensioners” cases (cited above), the present applications concern non-pecuniary compensations for health damage, which was a sole instantaneous act closely linked to the victims. Moreover the relatives of the late applicants failed to submit any evidence in respect of the acceptance of the late applicants’ inheritance. Having regard to the above mentioned circumstances, the Court considers that there is nothing in the cases at hand to conclude that the late applicants’ relatives have standing to continue proceedings.

    23.  As regards the applicants’ complaint under Article 6 of the Convention, the Court notes, that in the applications at hand the restoration of time-limit for appeal was closely related to the principle of legal certainty and of the “right to a court” (see, for instance, Sobelin and Others v. Russia, nos. 30672/03 and 11 others, § 67, 3 May 2007). However, since the restoration of the time-limit under Article 6 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention are closely interrelated, and considering that it has already rejected the relatives’ standing as regards the complaint under the latter provision of the Convention (see the paragraph above), the Court does not consider it necessary to draw a distinction between two aspects of the restoration of time-limit procedure for the purposes of determination of the standing issue.

    24.  Accordingly, the Court finds that Ms M. Arkhipova, Ms M. Kazbekova, Ms Z. Nastuyeva, Ms O. Lopatina, Ms L. Finogenova, Ms R. Shiklyasheva, Ms L. Neyevina and Ms M. Yermolova do not have a legitimate interest in pursuing the proceedings before the Court in the late applicants’ stead.

    25.  The Court does not consider that “respect for human rights, as defined in the Convention and the Protocols” requires the examination of these applications, despite the applicants’ death.

    26.  In these circumstances the Court considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications in part of the above mentioned applicants and concludes, under Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention, that they should be struck out of its list of cases.

    IV.  ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 OF THE CONVENTION

    27.  The applicants complained that the unlawful extension of the time-limit for appeal granted by the domestic courts following the defendant authority’s request had resulted in the judgments in their favour being quashed, which consequently constituted a violation of their right to a court. They relied on Article 6 § 1 of the Convention which, in so far as relevant, read as follows:

    Article 6 § 1

    “1.  In the determination of his civil rights and obligations ... everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law.”

    A.  Admissibility

    28.  The Government submitted from the outset that the domestic judgments in respect of some applicants had been executed in full prior to being quashed and they were not required to reimburse them afterwards (see “Enforcement status” in the Appendix). Consequently, the Government considered that the applicants had not suffered any significant disadvantage as a result of the domestic judgments in their favour being quashed.

    29.  The applicants maintained their claims.

    30.  Article 35 of the Convention provides as follows:

    “3.  The Court shall declare inadmissible any individual application submitted under Article 34 if it considers that:

    ...

    (b)  the applicant has not suffered a significant disadvantage, unless respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto requires an examination of the application on the merits and provided that no case may be rejected on this ground which has not been duly considered by a domestic tribunal.”

    31.  The Court notes at the outset that it has already addressed similar issue in the identical case Samoylenko and Others v. Russia (dec.) (nos. 58068/13 and 3 others, 7 March 2017). It thus does not see any ground to depart from the findings in that case.

    32.  The Court notes that the main aspect of this criterion is whether the applicant has suffered any significant disadvantage. The absence of any such disadvantage can be based on criteria such as the financial impact of the matter in dispute or the importance of the case for the applicant (see Adrian Mihai Ionescu v. Romania (dec.), no. 36659/04, § 33, 1 June 2010, with further references).

    33.  In the present case, the applicants do not dispute that the payments due under the initial judgments were made to them in full. Although these judgments were subsequently quashed, the domestic courts ruled that the applicants could not be required to repay the sums paid (see paragraph 10 above). Consequently, the financial implications of the proceedings could not present any particular hardship for the applicants.

    34.  As regards their claim that they had suffered distress on account of the enforcement proceedings, the Court observes that the judgments in their favour were quashed by the regional Supreme Court, which also ordered the reversal of the awards paid. The applicants then lodged a supervisory review application with the Presidium of the same court. It was open to them and their lawyers to request while lodging their supervisory review application that the enforcement proceedings be stayed (see paragraph 9 above). They could thus have avoided exposing themselves to the risk of having bailiffs attempt to seize their property pending the examination of their supervisory review application. They however failed to do so.

    35.  In these circumstances, the Court finds that the applicants did not suffer any “significant disadvantage”.

    36.  As to the question whether respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto requires an examination of the application on the merits, the Court points out that it has already held that respect for human rights does not require it to continue the examination of an application when, for example, the relevant law has changed and similar issues have been resolved in other cases before it (see Léger v. France (striking out) [GC], no. 19324/02, § 51, 30 March 2009).

    37.  The present case raises a problem of an unjustified extension of the time-limits for appeal resulting in a final judgment in the applicants’ favour being quashed, an issue which has already been addressed by the Court on several occasions, including in a case against Russia (see Magomedov and Others, cited above, §§ 98-101). The examination of these applications on the merits would not bring any new elements to the Court’s existing case-law (see Burov v. Moldova (dec.), no. 38875/03, § 33, 14 June 2011, and, by contrast, Mikhaylova v. Russia, no. 46998/08, § 49, 19 November 2015).

    38.  The Court therefore concludes that respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols does not require an examination of the applications on the merits.

    39.  Lastly, as regards the third condition of this inadmissibility criterion, namely that the case must have been “duly considered” by a domestic tribunal, the Court notes that the applicants’ case was subject to several rounds of domestic proceedings. The applicants were present at each hearing and were therefore able to submit their arguments in adversarial proceedings.

    40.  The three conditions of the inadmissibility criterion having therefore been satisfied, the Court finds that the applications must be declared inadmissible under Article 35 §§ 3 (b) and 4 of the Convention.

    41.  As regards the applications where the judgements in the applicants’ favour remained unenforced or the enforcement had been reversed and the paid amounts had been restored (see “Enforcement status” in the Appendix), the Court notes that the applicants’ complaints are not manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 of the Convention. It also notes that they are not inadmissible on any other grounds. They must therefore be declared admissible.

    B.  Merits

    42.  The Government considered that the present cases were similar to those previously examined by the Court and in which it did not find a violation of Article 6 (see, for instance, Tolstobrov v. Russia, no. 11612/05, 4 March 2010, and Protsenko v. Russia, no. 13151/04, 31 July 2008). They referred to the reasons stated by the Ministry of finance in its request for the reinstatement of the time-limit for appeal, namely that it had never been notified about the proceedings and the judgments delivered against it and was thus deprived of the possibility to lodge an appeal in due time. It is established and not disputed by the parties that a copy of the judgments had never been notified to the Ministry of finance or given to its representatives.

    43.  The applicants maintained their claims.

    44.  The Court reiterates that the existence of reasons capable of justifying a departure from the principle of legal certainty, even where they are established, is not in itself sufficient to conclude to the absence of a violation of Article 6 of the Convention. Another important factor should be taken into account, that is the time elapsed from the moment when the person requesting the extension of the time-limits became aware that a judgment was delivered against him. Since the extension of the time-limits for appeal constitutes an interference with the principle of res judicata, a person requesting such an extension should act with sufficient diligence, that is without delay from the moment when he became aware, or ought to have become aware, of the judgment subject to appeal (Magomedov and Others, cited above, § 89, with further references).

    45.  Turning to the circumstances of the present case, the Court recalls that it had already had an opportunity to examine the domestic proceedings complained of in the present case in its Magomedov and Others judgment (cited above), where it found a violation of Article 6 of the Convention on account of the domestic courts’ failure to examine when the Ministry became aware or “ought to have become aware” of the adoption of the judgments against it, in particular in view of a significant lapse of time between the delivery of those judgments and the introduction by the Ministry of its out-of-time appeals (Magomedov and Others, cited above, §§ 98-101). The Court does not see any reason to reach a different conclusion in the present case.

    46.  There has accordingly been a violation of Article 6 of the Convention.

    V.  ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 1 OF PROTOCOL No. 1 TO THE CONVENTION

    47.  Invoking Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention, cited above, the applicants further complained about violation of their right to the peaceful enjoyment of their possessions relying on the same facts. The relevant part of the aforementioned Article read as follows:

    Article 1 of Protocol No. 1

    “Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions. No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law.”

    48.  Having regard to its conclusion under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention, the Court considers that there is no need to consider either the admissibility or the merits of the complaint submitted by the applicants under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention (see Magomedov and Others, cited above, § 103, with numerous further references).

    VI.  APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION

    49.  Article 41 of the Convention provides:

    “If the Court finds that there has been a violation of the Convention or the Protocols thereto, and if the internal law of the High Contracting Party concerned allows only partial reparation to be made, the Court shall, if necessary, afford just satisfaction to the injured party.”

    A.  Damage

    50.  The applicants claimed full amounts awarded by the domestic courts.

    51.  The Government argued that no award should be made to the applicants, since they either lost their victim status or their Convention rights had not been violated.

    52.  The Court reiterates its finding that there had been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention on account of the interference with the principle of legal certainty. As regards the applicants’ claim for pecuniary damage, the Court does not see a causal link between the violation found and the alleged pecuniary damage and rejects those claims. Moreover, it considers that the finding of a violation constitutes in itself sufficient just satisfaction for any non-pecuniary damage which may have been suffered by the applicants.

    B.  Costs and expenses

    53.  Some of the applicants also claimed various amounts in respect of the costs and expenses.

    54.  The Government contested that amount, stating in particular that no evidence was provided by the applicants in support of their claim.

    55.  According to the case-law of the Court, an applicant can only be reimbursed for his costs and expenses in so far as their reality, necessity and reasonableness are established. In the present case, having regard to the documents before it and having regard to the findings of violations to which it has been subjected, the Court dismisses the claim for costs and expenses.

    FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT, UNANIMOUSLY,

    1.  Decides to join the applications;

     

    2.  Decides to strike the applications in part of the applicants indicated in the Appendix out of its list of cases;

     

    3.  Declares the applications in part of the applicants who did not receive the domestic courts’ awards admissible and the remainder of the applications inadmissible;

     

    4.  Holds that there has been a violation of Article 6 of the Convention;

     

    5.  Holds that it is not necessary to consider separately the admissibility and the merits of the complaints under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention;

     

    6.  Holds that the finding of a violation constitutes in itself sufficient just satisfaction for any non-pecuniary damage sustained by the applicants;

     

    7.  Dismisses the remainder of the applicants’ claim for just satisfaction.

    Done in English, and notified in writing on 7 November 2017, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.

         Fatoş Aracı                                                                    Luis López Guerra
    Deputy Registrar                                                                       President

     

     


    APPENDIX

    No.

    Application no.

    Lodged on

    Applicant

    Date of birth

    (Deceased on)

    (Heir)

    Place of residence

     

    Represented by

    Final domestic judgment

    date of delivery

    (date of becoming final)

    Quashing of the final judgments (and order to reverse the execution)

    Quashing of the reversal of the execution

    Strike out warning

    Enforcement status

    Strike out

    No significant disadvantage

    Violation

    1. 

    11421/13

    22/01/2013

    Khamid Khatutovich Kabardokov

    12/03/1949

    Tambovskoye

    Zaur Borisovich Geshev

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Viktor Vladimirovich Bocharnikov

    Russian

    19/04/1954

    Baksan

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Yuriy Khadisovich Gergov

    16/04/1947

    Baksan

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    20/11/2014

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Mukhadin Adamovich Dotkulov

    29/08/1949

    Baksan

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Zamir Misostovich Kardanov

    02/05/1951

    Baksan

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Gali Ezdanovich Shaov

    27/09/1956

    Baksan

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    2.      

    15459/13

    09/02/2013

    Baydulakh Magometovich Aytekov

    08/01/1952

    Khabaz

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Askerbiy Aslanovich Baysiyev

    29/09/1957

    Nalchik

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Ivan Grigoryevich Zaika

    18/02/1953

    Baksan

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    13/06/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Viktor Mikhaylovich Krementsov

    29/08/1955

    Prokhladnyy

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vasiliy Vasilyevich Popovich

    05/01/1953

    Prokhladnyy

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Mikhail Mikhaylovich Panchenko

    14/11/1954

    Mayskiy

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Ruslan Galiyevich Umarov

    02/03/1954

    Nalchik

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Sergey Ivanovich Sobakar

    04/09/1958

    Novo-Poltavskoye

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    3.      

    15625/13

    09/02/2013

    Timur Khasanovich Gukezhev

    07/09/1968

    Krasnoarmeyskoye

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    30/05/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Gisa Musayevich Guchapshev

    15/10/1956

    Tyrnyauz

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Isuf Abuzedovich Kumykov

    30/12/1955

    Psynadakha

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Mikhail Aniuarovich Sarakhov

    28/02/1957

    Terek

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Seyfu Yusufovich Khairov

    31/03/1954

    Novaya Balkariya

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Arsen Khasanbiyevich Urusmambetov

    29/10/1959

    Nartkala

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    30/05/2013

    24/082015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Muayed Khasanovich Khokonov

    15/08/1954

    Sarmakovo

     

    18/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    4.      

    15651/13

    09/02/2013

    Ivan Timofeyevich Arkhipov

    17/10/1945

    09/02/2015

    (Marina Aleksandrovna Arkhipova) Mayskiy

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Muayed Sultanovich Gedmishkhov

    23/05/1957

    Kuba-Taba

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksey Dmitriyevich Dadonov

    19/03/1951

    28/04/2014

    (Olga Alekseyevna Lopatina)

    Kotlyarevskaya

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Khasen Vladimirovich Zhuzhuyev

    05/10/1964

    Zolskoye

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vladimir Andreyevich Kudritskiy

    16/11/1954

    Mayskiy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksandr Alekseyevich Larin

    18/05/1957

    Kotlyarevskaya

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    27/02/2015

    (loss of interest)

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Nikolay Fedorovich Menyaylo

    12/08/1951

    Mayskiy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vladimir Abramovich Shpakov

    15/09/1952

    Kotlyarevskaya

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    21/10/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Zhora Khasanovich Erzhibov

    12/05/1953

    Nartkala

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

    30/05/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    5.      

    18295/13

    20/02/2013

    Saladin Khautiyevich Taov

    15/12/1950

    Nalchik

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Stanislav Sergeyevich Anosov

    02/09/1954

    Nalchik

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    10/04/2014

     

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Aleksandr Aleksandrovich Borisenko

    25/03/1954

    Katlyarevskaya

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Sergey Maratovich Magomedov

    21/04/1954

    Kashkhatau

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    10/04/2014

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Ruslan Khadisovich Misrokov

    29/04/1968

    Prokhladnyy

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksandr Nikolayevich Sviridenko

    16/07/1952

    Nalchik

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    10/04/2014

    21/10/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Sultan Batyrbiyevich Khamshokov

    07/11/1968

    Arik

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    6.      

    19142/13

    22/02/2013

    Khasym Yusupovich Bittirov

    31/12/1956

    Gerpegezh

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    05/04/2011

    (18/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    20/11/2014

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Aleksandr Mukharbiyevich Zrumov

    14/04/1950

    Nalchik

     

    05/04/2011

    (18/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Viktor Khazhmuratovich Kugotov

    02/04/1956

    Kamennomostskoye

     

    05/04/2011

    (18/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    7.      

    19156/13

    22/02/2013

    Serezha Sharapiyevich Zholayev

    05/11/1952

    Novaya Balkariya

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Zaurbi Bilyalovich Kardanov

    11/11/1964

    Kuba-Taba

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Valeriy Mukhazhidovich Khagov

    08/11/1951

    Urozhaynoye

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Mukhamed Mukhametovich Kazbekov

    13/02/1948

    29/04/2013

    (Mayya Lakhmanovna Kazbekova)

    Deyskoye

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Mukhamed Matsovich Shabazov

    20/07/1946

    Tyrnyauz

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Enforced, then reversed

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Boris Sufiyanovich Nastuyev

    17/04/1953

    27/02/2013

    (Zaynaf Abdullayevna Nastuyeva)

    Verkhnyaya Zhemtala

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Khasan Safarbiyevich Gergov

    10/06/1959

    Nalchik

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    21/10/2015

    Enforced, then reversed

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Anatoliy Semenovich Zavgorodniy

    10/05/1935

    Prokhladnyy

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Gennadiy Mukhamedovich Shkhanukov

    08/09/1954

    Nalchik

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Khashaua Anibalovich Yemkuzhev

    18/12/1955

    Urozhaynoye

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vladimir Petrovich Yepishin

    27/09/1954

    Terek

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Gissa Machrailovich Apikov

    01/11/1966

    Shalushka

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    8.      

    19161/13

    14/02/2013

    Auyes Khapitovich Tsirkhov

    07/03/1953

    Nalchik

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Yuriy Alekseyevich Nekrasov

    25/05/1951

    Prokhladnyy

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Nikolay Ivanovich Khrushchev

    05/12/1926

    Prokhladnyy

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vasiliy Maksimovich Lashin

    25/01/1939

    Priblizhnaya

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Anatoliy Alekseyevich Varchenko

    28/08/1941

    Prokhladnyy

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Magarram Vali Ogly Nasibov

    15/07/1939

    Priblizhnaya

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    13/06/2013

    24/08/2015

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Vladimir Ivanovich Parshakov

    16/03/1949

    Prokhladnyy

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    13/06/2013

    24/08/2015

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Viktor Nikolayevich Yurchenko

    25/07/1954

    Primalkinskoye

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vasiliy Alekseyevich Bobrovenko

    22/04/1930

    Prokhladnyy

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vladimir Timofeyevich Savchenko

    09/09/1939

    Prokhladnyy

     

    11/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    9.      

    19398/13

    13/02/2013

    Murik Blitovich Boriyev

    09/12/1955

    Nalchik

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    14/02/2011

    (25/02/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

    21/10/2015

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Anatoliy Adalgeriyevich Kumykov

    25/05/1952

    Baksan

     

    14/02/2011

    (25/02/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Mukhazhid Mukhamedovich Organokov

    04/12/1949

    Baksan

     

    14/02/2011

    (25/02/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Sergey Semenovich Panyakin

    02/12/1954

    Prokhladnyy

     

    14/02/2011

    (25/02/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Boris Timofeyevich Khokhlachev

    11/03/1953

    Nalchik

     

    14/02/2011

    (25/02/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    10.   

    19408/13

    14/02/2013

    Nikolay Konstantinovich Apanasenko

    25/11/1938

    17/07/2013

    (Lidiya Yevteyevna Neyevina)

    Mayskiy

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Oleg Valentinovich Volodin

    28/08/1968

    Mayskiy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Viktor Vladimirovich Glybin

    22/08/1951

    Nalchik

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Enforced but then reversed

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Viktor Ivanovich Klochkov

    15/01/1950

    Prokhladnyy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Viktor Petrovich Likhtinov

    25/04/1952

    Mayskiy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    21/10/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Amir Musarbiyevich Pshigusov

    01/12/1957

    Zaragizh

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Khasan Kilchukovich Sizhazhev

    10/12/1949

    Tyrnyauz

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Nikolay Grigoryevich Chikalenko

    08/03/1955

    Kotlyarevskaya

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Enforced but then reversed

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Timosha Khazhpagovich Shadov

    20/07/1956

    Tambovskoye

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    11.   

    19549/13

    11/02/2013

    Igor Grigoryevich Gredasov

    23/12/1946

    Kashkhatau

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

    16/05/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Boris Ivanovich Degtyarenko

    09/02/1940

    Yekaterinogradskaya

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Khamid Bubovich Kardanov

    23/12/1954

    Zalukokoazhe

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Yaroslav Yaroslavovich Morsin

    04/08/1965

    Mayskiy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Nikolay Petrovich Potapkin

    25/11/1954

    Nalchik

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksandr Dmitriyevich Semochkin

    26/07/1954

    Priblizhnaya

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

    16/05/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Viktor Gennadyevich Shvedov

    24/05/1954

    Prokhladnyy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Igor Aleksandrovich Yurlov

    20/06/1965

    Nalchik

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    12.   

    19687/13

    11/02/2013

    Khusen Mazanovich Aybazov

    28/02/1948

    Krem-Konstantinovskoye

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

    24/08/2015

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Kharun Satyvaldyyevich Gyzyyev

    01/09/1956

    Kashkhatau

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Aleksandr Viktorovich Kostenko

    18/11/1965

    Baksan

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Zhamal Zhapayevich Kulbayev

    24/01/1951

    Kashkhatau

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Dmitriy Anatolyevich Minin

    19/05/1955

    Priblizhnaya

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Mustafir Muradinovich Osmanov

    11/05/1956

    Kendelen

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

    14/11/2015

    Loss of interest

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Aleksandr Nikolayevich Finogenov

    27/02/1953

    25/02/2015

    (Lyudmila Konstantinovna Finogenova)

    Mayskiy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    13.   

    19697/13

    11/02/2013

    Viktor Ivanovich Bidak

    21/11/1950

    Prokhladnyy

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vladimir Aleksandrovich Budnikov

    18/05/1957

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Anatoliy Khambiyevich Dokhov

    18/10/1954

    Zhemtala

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    30/05/2013

     

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Khazhmurat Yakhyayevich Dzhankulayev

    19/08/1966

    Terek

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    30/05/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Nikolay Mikhaylovich Mukozhev

    06/03/1966

    Terek

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Alisag Mukhamedovich Takhushev

    04/08/1953

    Terek

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksandr Nikolayevich Stepanenko

    27/02/1957

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vyacheslav Anibalovich Tsirkhov

    06/02/1966

    Beloglinskoye

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    14.   

    19722/13

    13/02/2013

    Mutalis Mikhaylovich Alkhasov

    18/10/1967

    Atazhukina

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Khyzyr Khadzhimuratovich Kabardokov

    12/08/1954

    Nalchik

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    20/11/2014

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Anatoliy Talevich Kongapshev

    30/01/1951

    Karagach

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksandr Nikolayevich Plakhov

    01/06/1949

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Vasiliy Ilyich Strizhak

    13/07/1954

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Akhmet Khasultanovich Kharsiyev

    02/01/1955

    Babugent

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    20/11/2014

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Makhamadzhan Narbayevich Khaynazarov

    01/05/1954

    Kashkhatau

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    Enforced but then reversed

    24/08/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Aleksandr Aleksandrovich Chernyshov

    03/12/1949

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Nikolay Khadinovich Shiklyashev

    02/02/1954

    01/06/2013

    (Raya Khasanbiyevna Shiklyasheva)

    Terek

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    15.   

    22925/13

    13/02/2013

    Sergey Sobirovich Abdurakhmonov

    14/06/1963

    Prokhladnyy

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Ruslan Khazhislamovich Gongapshev

    13/10/1954

    Sarmakovo

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Vladimir Anatolyevich Derepovko

    26/02/1940

    Prokhladnyy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Valeriy Aleksandrovich Korovin

    09/09/1952

    Terek

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksey Timofeyevich Kozlovtsev

    23/01/1952

    Baksan

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Sergey Petrovich Laptev

    30/07/1957

    Priblizhnaya

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

    16/05/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Pavel Alekseyevich Nikitenko

    18/12/1954

    Mayskiy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Muayed Mastafovich Surmametov

    07/02/1956

    Zaragizh

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

     

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Zaurbek Ismagilovich Shanibov

    12/02/1959

    Nalchik

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

    16/05/2013

    24/08/2015

     

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    16.   

    22935/13

    13/02/2013

    Eduard Chartiyevich Abazov

    17/06/1968

    Dygulubgey

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Fedya Khuseynovich Zhemgurazov

    29/07/1956

    Zhemtala

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Sergey Konstantinovich Zykov

    25/09/1953

    Novo-Pokrovskiy

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

    13/06/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Yevgeniy Nikolayevich Lazarev

    09/02/1947

    Baksan

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    17.   

    22953/13

    25/02/2013

    Tobi Khasanbiyevich Kushkhov

    07/02/1953

    Baksan

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    20/11/2014

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Vladimir Kurgokovich Sibilov

    10/08/1949

    Dzhulat

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Viktor Andreyevich Khalin

    27/09/1954

    Novoye Khamidiye

     

    12/04/2011

    (25/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    18.   

    23006/13

    12/02/2013

    Shota Aleksandrovich Yermolov

    10/07/1939

    16/10/2015

    (Marina Shotayevna Yermolova) Yekaterinogradskaya

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    11/04/2011

    (21/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    16/05/2013

    21/10/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Vasiliy Ivanovich Shevyakov

    01/09/1947

    Mayskiy

     

    11/04/2011

    (21/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Eduard Borisovich Chikhradze

    14/08/1967

    Nalchik

     

    11/04/2011

    (21/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Valentina Grigoryevna Polyakova

    07/07/1935

    Nalchik

     

    11/04/2011

    (21/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    16/05/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Khuseyn Seyfullakhovich Gekkiyev

    06/01/1968

    Tyrnyauz

     

    11/04/2011

    (21/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    16/05/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Sergey Otarovich Gobedzhishvili

    03/01/1967

    Nalchik

     

    11/04/2011

    (21/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Anatoliy Khizirovich Zhambikov

    10/12/1939

    Nalchik

     

    11/04/2011

    (21/04/2011)

    12/10/2012

    16/05/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    19.   

    23109/13

    13/02/2013

    Mikhail Vladimirovich Belunin

    01/01/1955

    Prokhladnyy

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Nikolay Nikolayevich Marchenko

    24/07/1949

    Prokhladnyy

     

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    16/05/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Gennadiy Andreyevich Moiseyenko

    28/05/1949

    Mayskiy

     

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Yuriy Grigoryevich Medvedev

    23/10/1955

    Mayskiy

     

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    16/05/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Talgat Avzalovich Nurmukhametov

    01/01/1947

    Prokhladnyy

     

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    16/05/2013

    21/10/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Aleksandr Vladimirovich Pinyayev

    06/06/1952

    Mayskiy

     

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    16/05/2013

    21/10/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Petr Ivanovich Slipenko

    15/08/1958

    Prokhladnyy

     

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Tayib Ayubovich Tadzhibov

    14/11/1958

    Tyrnyauz

     

    16/02/2011

    (01/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    16/05/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    20.   

    23135/13

    13/02/2013

    Ivan Semenovich Kachanov

    10/08/1942

    Primalkinskoye

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Viktor Petrovich Lichmanov

    16/08/1947

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Sergey Timofeyevich Nikolayev

    24/12/1954

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Yuriy Stepanovich Obukhov

    25/09/1950

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Garri Mikhaylovich Pogosov

    03/01/1958

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Sergey Leonidovich Sadovoy

    31/08/1962

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

    16/05/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Sergey Viktorovich Kharitonov

    19/10/1950

    Prokhladnyy

     

    04/04/2011

    (15/04/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    21.   

    23145/13

    13/02/2013

    Valeriy Akhmatovich Gurtuyev

    01/03/1968

    Gerpegezh

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Muayed Khusenovich Ligidov

    29/08/1950

    Sarmakovo

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Mukhamed Anatolyevich Maremshaov

    25/10/1950

    Nalchik

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

    30/05/2013

    21/10/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Vasiliy Ivanovich Martynyuk

    23/09/1951

    Nalchik

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Zamir Gumarovich Tukhuzhev

    11/12/1956

    Nartan

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Khusein Abdullayevich Shakhabov

    03/04/1955

    Kashkhatau

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Nikolay Yakovlevich Shtelvakh

    19/06/1956

    Terek

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Mukharbek

    Mukhadinovich Shomakhov

    29/11/1962

    Nizhniy Akbash

     

    12/04/2011

    (22/04/2011)

    10/10/2012

    30/05/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    22.   

    26466/13

    11/02/2013

    Muzafar Tatukovich Atabiyev

    13/05/1966

    Nalchik

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

    21/10/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Boris Aliyevich Beppayev

    25/01/1956

    Nalchik

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Aleksandr Vladimirovich Katasonov

    28/08/1952

    Nalchik

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

    24/08/2015

    Unenforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Khachim Dinovich Pshikhachev

    29/09/1957

    Baksan

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

    24/08/2015

    Enforced

    Strike out

     

     

    Ruslan Yuryevich Tumov

    28/07/1968

    Terek

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

    13/06/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

    Aniuar Zhansitovich Taov

    07/04/1955

    Terek

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Aleksandr Amirkhanovich Shomakhov

    10/06/1955

    Tambovskoye

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    Eduard Dikanovich Shomakhov

    28/02/1956

    Terek

     

    10/03/2011

    (22/03/2011)

    07/09/2012

     

     

    Unenforced

     

     

    Violation of Article 6 of the Convention

    23.   

    58066/13

    26/08/2013

    Ruslan Marufovich Nishanov

    07/06/1964

    Nalchik

     

    Magamed Saltanmuratovich Abubakarov

    17/01/2011

    (27/02/2011)

    28/02/2013

    11/07/2013

     

    Enforced

     

    No significant disadvantage

     

     


BAILII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Donate to BAILII
URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2017/971.html