BAILII [Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] [DONATE]

Abu Dhabi Global Market judgments (Court of First Instance)


You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> Abu Dhabi Global Market judgments (Court of First Instance) >> THE BIRDS ELECTRO-MECHANICAL CONTRACTING COMPANY - LLC v SOCIETE D,ENTREPRISE & DE GESTATION EMIRATES CONTRACTING LLC [2026] ADGMCFI 0023 (07 August 2026)
URL: https://www.bailii.org/ae/cases/ADGMCFI/2026/23.html
Cite as: [2026] ADGMCFI 0023, [2026] ADGMCFI 23

[New search] [Contents list] [Printable PDF version] [Help]


 

In the name of
His Highness Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan
President of the United Arab Emirates/ Ruler of the Emirate of Abu Dhabi

 

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
COMMERCIAL AND CIVIL DIVISION

BETWEEN

 

THE BIRDS ELECTRO-MECHANICAL CONTRACTING COMPANY - LLC

Claimant

and

 

SOCIÉTÉ D,ENTREPRISE & DE GESTATION EMIRATES CONTRACTING LLC

First Defendant

 

RAK PROPERTIES CO PUBLIC JSC

Second Defendant

 

 

JUDGMENT OF JUSTICE PAUL HEATH KC


 

 

Neutral Citation:

[2026] ADGMCFI 0023

Before:

Justice Paul Heath KC

Decision Date:

7 August 2026

Decision:

1.      The Second Defendant's Set Aside Application be dismissed. 

2.      The Second Defendant shall pay the Claimant's costs of the Set Aside Application, to be summarily assessed on the standard basis if not agreed. The parties shall advise the Registry if agreement were not reached. On receipt of such notice, the Court will issue directions for the exchange of submissions on questions of costs (including statements of costs required under Practice Direction 9) and determine quantum on the papers.

Hearing Date(s):

(On the papers)

Date of Orders:

7 August 2026

Catchwords:

Default judgment. Application to set aside. Whether there is a real prospect of successfully defending the claim.

Legislation Cited:

ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016

Cases Cited:

Al Khaleej Investment P.S.C v Ocean Pearl Real Estate Company LLC [2025] ADGMCFI 0012

Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465

 

Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd v James Kemball Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 33

 

Laktineh & Co Ltd v Ahmed Al Hatta & Anor [2020] ADGMCFI 0001

Playboy Club London Ltd v Banca Nazionale del Lavoro SpA [2018] UKSC 43

 

Spire Property Development LLP v Withers LLP [2023] 4 WLR 56

 

URS Corporation Ltd v BDW Trading Ltd [2023] EWCA Civ 772


Union Properties PJSC v Trinkler and Partners Ltd [2024] ADGMCFI 0014

Case Number:

ADGMCFI-2026-075

Parties and representation:

Mr. Mohamed Ali Nurul Alam as the authorised officer of the Claimant

 

Mr. Richard Bell of Al Tamimi & Company for the Second Defendant

 

JUDGMENT

Introduction

1.             On 5 February 2026, The Birds Electro-Mechanical Contracting Co - LLC ("Birds Electro-Mechanical") filed a claim by which judgment was sought against two companies Société D,Entreprise & De Gestation Emirates Contracting LLC ("SEG") [1] and RAK Properties Co Public JSC ("RAK Properties") in the sum of AED 2,887,861, plus interest and costs. The Claim arose out of a Subcontracting Agreement dated 29 November 2017 (the "Subcontracting Agreement") pursuant to which Birds Electro-Mechanical undertook electrical and mechanical works for the Julphar Residence Project, on Al Reem Island. Only Birds Electro-Mechanical and SEG were parties to the Subcontracting Agreement.

2.             The Registry served both SEG and RAK Properties with the Claim on 6 February 2026. [2] Both were served by email sent at 11.14am. RAK Properties was also served by a WhatsApp message sent at 10.42am on the same day. No acknowledgment of service was filed. [3] As a result, on 14 March 2026, Birds Electro-Mechanical applied for the entry of a default judgment (the "Default Judgment Application") against both SEG and RAK Properties.

3.             On 25 March 2026, the Court entered judgment (the "Default Judgment") on a joint and several basis against both SEG and RAK Properties in the sum of USD 786,347.45, which was the claimed sum of AED 2,887,861 converted at the Abu Dhabi Global Market ("ADGM") Court's approved rate. [4] Interest on that amount was awarded at the rate of 5% per annum from the date of judgment, together with filing fees. [5] Subsequently, on 17 April 2026, costs were fixed in the sum of AED 15,000, also payable jointly and severally by SEG and RAK Properties (the "Costs Order"). [6]

4.             Enforcement orders were issued in respect of the Default Judgment on 6 May 2026 and the Costs Order on 12 May 2026. Just over a month later, on 18 June 2026, RAK Properties applied to set aside the Default Judgment (the "Set Aside Application"). No steps have been taken by SEG to challenge the Default Judgment. The Set Aside Application is opposed by Birds Electro-Mechanical.

The Set Aside Application

5.             RAK Properties advances its Set Aside Application on two grounds:

a.             Service of the Claim was not validly effected in accordance with the ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016 (the "Rules") and any relevant practice direction (the "Service Issue"); [7] and

b.             In any event, RAK Properties has a "real prospect" of successfully defending the claim (the "Merits Issue"). [8]

The Service Issue

6.             I addressed the Service Issue when entering Default Judgment on 25 March 2026. I said: [9]

"3.          With respect to service of the Claim: (i) [SEG] was served via the email listed on its trade licence; and (ii) [RAK Properties] was served via WhatsApp to the mobile telephone number listed on its trade licence. While the trade licences relied upon by the Claimant are not recent and show expired dates on their face, the Court is satisfied that service has been validly effected for the purposes of entering default judgment. It remains open to the Defendants to seek to set the default judgment aside."

7.             A Claim form that is sent to a defendant by means of an email or a WhatsApp message is "deemed" to have been served on the day it was sent (if before 4pm GST) or the following day (if after 4pm GST). [10] In this case, both the email and the WhatsApp messages were sent on the morning of 6 February 2026, [11] meaning that service was deemed to have been effected on that day.

8.             In a witness statement dated 18 June 2026, in support of the Set Aside Application, ("Mathew 1") Mr Jeffin Mathew, "Specialist-Administration" at RAK Properties, explained that company's position with regard to service:

"II.         SERVICE OF THE CLAIM

6.        I understand that [Birds Electro-Mechanical] and/or the ADGM Courts Registry attempted to effect service of the Claim on RAK Properties, by way of:

a.            an email addressed to: adminoffice@rakproperties.ae (the "Email Address"). I understand that this email was sent on or around 6 February 2026 (the "6 February Email"); and

b.            by WhatsApp to the mobile number 050 377 7075, being the number listed on [RAK Properties] trade licence.

7.        I have investigated the service of the Claim on [RAK Properties] and set out my findings below.

Service of the Claim by email

8.            The Email Address is a general administrative email address maintained by RAK Properties, to which I have access in the ordinary course of my duties.

9.        RAK Properties first became aware of the existence of these proceedings on 11 May 2026, when it received an email from the ADGM Courts Registry attaching the Default Judgment and an order of Justice Paul Heath KC directing the Defendants to pay [Birds Electro-Mechanical's] costs (the "Costs Order") (the "11 May Email").

10.      Upon receiving the 11 May Email, I immediately forwarded it to RAK Properties' legal department. Mr Abdallah Al Akhdar, Assistant Manager - Legal & Investor Relations, subsequently asked me to confirm whether any prior correspondence had been received from the ADGM Courts Registry. I confirmed that, to the best of my knowledge, no such correspondence had been received.

11.      I have reviewed the email account for the Email Address and can find no record of [RAK Properties] having received the 6 February Email in the inbox. I attach a screenshot of the inbox for the whole of the day of 6 February 2026.

Service of the claim by WhatsApp

12.      I am informed by RAK Properties' legal representatives that the Default Judgment records the claim as having been served on RAK Properties via WhatsApp to mobile number 050 377 7075, being the number listed on RAK Properties' trade licence.

13.      I obtained a screenshot from Mr Khaled Mohammed, who has access to the WhatsApp account associated with that number. The screenshot covers the period from 2 February 2026 to 16 February 2026 and shows that the claim was not received during that window.

                Service of the Default Judgment

14.      As set out above, on or around 11 May 2026, RAK Properties received the 11 May Email from the ADGM Courts Registry attaching the Default Judgment and the Costs Order.

15.      The receipt of the 11 May Email was the first time that RAK Properties first became aware of the Claim and of the existence of these proceedings."

(Emphasis added)

9.             In the case of a corporate defendant such as RAK Properties, rules 15(1), (2)(a) and (b), (3)(c), 16A(1)(a), (b) and 16B(1) and (3) are relevant. They provide:

"15.   Methods of service

(1)       This Part applies to the service of documents except where any rule, practice direction, ADGM enactment or a Court order requires that a document, including a claim form, must be served by any other method.

...

Methods of service - claim form

(2)       The registry will serve the claim form on the defendant by any method permitted under Part 4 of these Rules, unless:

             (a) a defendant is to be served outside the United Arab Emirates, in which case the claim form must be served on the defendant by the claimant...; or

             (b)  any rule, practice direction, ADGM enactment or Court order provides otherwise.

(3)       Subject to paragraphs (4) to (8) below, a claim form may be served –

...

             (c)  by email or other means of electronic communication in accordance with Rule 16B;

..."

"16A. Service on a company, partnership or any other entity

(1)       A claim form is served on a company by:

(a)       leaving it at, or sending it by post to, the company's registered office or any place of business of the company which has a real connection with the claim; or

(b)       any other method permitted under this Part.

...

16B. Service by email or other means of electronic communication

(1)       A claim form may be served electronically.

...

(3)       A claim form is served electronically on a person -

(a)       by email, provided that it must be shown that the email account to which the document is sent belongs to the person to be served;

(b)       by mobile text message (SMS), WhatsApp or like messaging, provided that it must be shown that the mobile number to which the document, or notice of the document, is sent belongs to the person to be served; or

(c)       by email, mobile text message, (SMS), WhatsApp or like messaging to a lawyer nominated by the person to be served as authorised to accept service.

...."

(Emphasis added)

10.         The Registry filed a Notice of Service of Claim Form in Commercial and Civil Division (the "Notice of Service") on 20 February 2026, noting that service had been effected on RAK Properties by email at 11.14am on 6 February 2026 and WhatsApp message on the same day at 10.42am.  When service of a Claim is effected on a company by electronic means, "it must be shown that [the email account or the mobile number] to which the document [has been sent] belongs to the person to be served". [12] Once that criterion has been met, service is deemed to have been effected validly. [13]

11.         Practice Direction 6 ("PD 6") sets out the grounds on which the Court determines whether an email account or a WhatsApp mobile number "belongs to" the person to be served, for the purposes of service of a Claim under rule 15 of the Rules. [14] The Court must determine whether a particular email address or WhatsApp mobile number "belongs to" the person to be served by reference to the various means set out in paragraph 6.18 of PD 6. [15] In addition to a number of specific grounds, paragraph 6.18(g) of PD 6 more generally authorises: "any other means which reasonably shows that the email account belongs to the person to be served". A similar provision in relation to WhatsApp messages is contained in paragraph 6.22(g) of PD 6.

12.         I am satisfied that both the email address and the mobile number used for the purposes of service "belong to" RAK Properties. RAK Properties' own evidence confirms that state of affairs. Mr Mathew acknowledges that the email address is "a general administrative email address maintained by RAK Properties, to which [he had] access in the ordinary course of [his] duties". He also confirmed that the WhatsApp message was sent to a mobile number listed on RAK Properties' trade licence. [16]

13.         ADGM has taken a policy decision to permit service to be effected by electronic means, with proof of service being established by evidence that the relevant electronic communication (in this case, email or WhatsApp message) has been sent to an account that "belongs to" the person to be served. The Registry's Notice of Service of 20 February 2026 confirms that the email and WhatsApp messages were sent to RAK Properties at 11.14am and 10.42am respectively. [17] Whether RAK Properties did or did not receive the email or WhatsApp message is not relevant to the question whether valid service has been effected.

14.         In determining whether an email or message was sent to an account or mobile number that belonged to the person to be served, the focus is on whether the electronic communication was sent rather than received by the person to be served. I considered a similar issue in Al Khaleej Investment PSC v Ocean Pearl Real Estate Company LLC, in the context of an email address that remained on a government or official record that showed it belonged to the person to be served. My observations apply with equal force in the present case. I said: [18]

"19. It is important for all persons served with claim forms to understand the variety of means by which service may be effected, and that those methods may differ from what the recipient may perceive to have been a better option. This case illustrates the need for companies to keep email contact addresses up to date on official or government documents.

20.   In this case, once Mr Sultan received the claim form at his email address, service was validly effected upon Ocean Pearl. It was therefore necessary for an extension of time to be sought to file an Acknowledgment of Service and a Defence. The fact that, as Ms Tawfik states, Mr Sultan's email address had been inserted on the Ministry of Economy's form as a contact point during the company's establishment process and he did not have express authority to accept service on behalf of Ocean Pearl is beside the point."

15.         That approach does not leave a party in the position of RAK Properties without a remedy in circumstances where it wishes to challenge the entry of a default judgment. While it removes the ability of such a party to have a default judgment set aside as of right, the ability to seek an order to that effect is retained. The difference lies in the need for the defendant to establish grounds on which it has a real prospect of defending the Claim. [19]

16.         I hold that service has been validly effected. The question whether the Default Judgment should be set aside must be determined by reference to the Merits Issue.

The Merits Issue

(a)           Legal principles

17.         Rule 41 of the Rules deals with the circumstances in which an application to set aside a default judgment may succeed. Relevantly, rule 41 provides:

"41.             Setting aside or varying default judgment

...

(2) In any other case, the Court may set aside or vary a judgment entered under Rule 39, ...:

(a) if the defendant has a real prospect of successfully defending the claim; or

(b) if it appears to the Court that there is some other good reason why the judgment should be set aside or varied or the defendant should be allowed to defend the claim; and

(c) the application to set aside or vary the judgment was made promptly.

(3) An application under this Rule must be supported by evidence."

18.         The Merits Issue falls to be determined by reference to whether RAK Properties: (a) made the Set Aside Application promptly; and (b) can demonstrate that it has a "real prospect of successfully defending the claim".

 

19.         As to the need for a "prompt" application, this Court, in Laktineh & Co Ltd v Ahmed Al Hatta, [20] said that the question should be approached by reference to the principle of finality in litigation, taking into account the risk of injustice if too strict an approach is taken to interpretation of the word "promptly". [21] In that case, the Court refused to set aside a default judgment because it had not been made sufficiently promptly even though it also found that the relevant defendant had a real prospect of successfully defending the claim. [22] In doing so, Justice Lord McGhie was influenced significantly by the defendant's conduct. That is the explanation for what otherwise might be regarded as a harsh exercise of discretion.

 

20.         In my view, compelling circumstances (of the type described in Laktineh) will generally be required to persuade the Court not to set aside a default judgment in circumstances where it is satisfied that the defendant has a real prospect of successfully defending the claim. That said, I do not propose to dwell on this topic. The Set Aside Application was filed just over one month after RAK Properties became aware of the default judgment having been entered. [23] I prefer to determine the Set Aside Application by reference solely to whether RAK Properties has a defence on which it has a real prospect of succeeding at trial. For present purposes, I hold that the Set Aside Application was filed in a sufficiently timely manner.

 

21.         The phrase "real prospect" of successfully defending the claim is one that appears in various parts of the Rules. Illustrations are its use in the context of applications for summary judgment [24] and applications for permission to appeal. [25] The term has been the subject of judicial interpretation in a number of cases. While some allowance needs to be made for the nature of the application in issue, it is necessary to ensure consistency of approach in evaluating whether a "real prospect" of success has been established.

 

22.         In delivering the principal judgment of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales in Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd v James Kemball Ltd, [26] Popplewell LJ said that it was "not enough that the claim is merely arguable; it must carry some degree of conviction". [27] A similar approach was taken by Justice Sir Andrew Smith in this Court in Union Properties PJSC v Trinkler and Partners Ltd, in which he observed that the question was whether there was a realistic, as opposed to a fanciful, prospect of success. [28] In the later decision of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales in URS Corporation Ltd v BDW Trading Ltd, [29] the Court described the test as "one of reasonable arguability". [30] Although expressed in different ways, the fundamental test remains whether (for the purposes of the Set Aside Application) there is a realistic prospect that RAK Properties can successfully defend the claim.

 

(b)           Grounds of Defence

23.         RAK Properties advances two grounds on which it contends that it has a real prospect of defending Birds Electro-Mechanical's Claim:

a.             The first is that RAK Properties was not a party to the Subcontracting Agreement. RAK Properties' position is that it has no direct contractual liability to Birds Electro-Mechanical.

b.             The second is that there are no other circumstances on which Birds Electro-Mechanical can rely to establish the assumption of a "direct, binding and unconditional obligation" to pay the amounts owing to Birds Electro-Mechanical under the Subcontracting Agreement. This point involves consideration of a document headed "No Objection to Direct Payment Certificate" dated 19 April 2021 (the "Direct Payment NOC"). [31]

24.         Alternatively, if I were not persuaded that those two grounds had a real prospect of success, RAK Properties contends that the Direct Payment NOC arrangement does not constitute a guarantee of the obligation of SEG (as contractor) to pay Birds Electro-Mechanical all moneys owing under the Subcontracting Agreement. RAK Properties' alternative position has been put without prejudice to its primary contention that it is not a party to the Direct Payment NOC.

25.         I remind myself that the onus of establishing a real prospect of successfully defending the proceeding rests on RAK Properties.

 

(c)           Context

26.         The Claim arises out of work undertaken on the Julphar Residence Project on Al Reem Island. RAK Properties, as developer, entered into a contract with SEG to undertake the development. In turn, SEG subcontracted electrical and mechanical work to Birds Electro-Mechanical. Another company, Arkonsult Engineering Consultancy ("Arkonsult"), was engaged by RAK Properties as its "project consultant". Generally speaking, in construction projects of this nature, an engineer will typically act as the employer's agent when issuing instructions and managing the project. Arkonsult was responsible for monitoring progress of the works. It follows that on many occasions it will have acted as RAK Properties' agent in doing so.

27.         By 19 April 2021, difficulties had arisen in relation to payment of Birds Electro-Mechanical for remaining contract works that it was obliged to perform under the Subcontracting Agreement. Discussions took place among relevant parties on that issue. The Direct Payment NOC was the outcome of those discussions. The parties that executed the Direct Payment NOC were Birds Electro-Mechanical, SEG and Arkonsult. It is common ground that RAK Properties was not a signatory to the document. What is clear, however, is that the underlying reason for the Direct Payment NOC was the need to satisfy Birds Electro-Mechanical that it would be paid for future required services to complete its contracted work. The obvious inference to be drawn is that, without the Direct Payment NOC, there was a risk that Birds Electro-Mechanical may remove itself from the site, to the detriment of RAK Properties.

28.         Relevantly, the Direct Payment NOC of 19 April 2021 provided:

"... [Birds Electro-Mechanical], hereby confirm that we shall complete all balance works, provide all required certification and documentation for handing over to civil defense the relevant authority to obtain [a Building Completion Certificate].

SEG do not have any objection for [RAK Properties] direct payment against the due and remaining amounts for the favors of the subcontractor as below noted:

a.         Certified Amount: AED: 247,390.3 (including VAT) Due against the work progress certified by SEG with receipt of Tax Invoice from Subcontractor.

b.         Balance amount: AED: 506,787.25 (Excluding VAT) (Amount may vary based on final certification approval by the Engineer/Contractor) shall be certified upon submission and approval of all Operation manuals, as built drawings and any other related documents required for building handing over in accordance with conditions of contract.

c.         50% of Retention amount: AED: 976,960.16 (Excluding VAT) (Amount may vary based on final certification approval by the Engineer/Contractor) shall be released as per the Subcontract agreement on TOC & Issuance of Completion Certificate.

d.         50% Retention amount AED 976,960.16 (Excluding VAT) (Amount may vary based on final certification approval by the Engineer/Contractor) on completion of DLP & issuance of End of Maintenance Certificate.

This NOC will be valid once Subcontractor submits all documents related to Authority approvals and handing over to the above mentioned project and issuance of Building Completion Certificate.

Furthermore, SEG confirms that any such payment made by [RAK Properties] to Suppliers/Sub Contractor shall be considered as Payment to SEG and hence the amount paid shall be deducted by way of set-off from SEG account".

29.         From the evidence before me, it is an irresistible inference that Arkonsult acted as its agent in relation to the Direct Payment NOC. That inference derives from the commercial logic of a company such as Arkonsult signing such a document on behalf of a principal and the absence of any reason why Arkonsult would have been a signatory to the Direct Payment NOC unless it did so to bind its principal, RAK Properties, to an obligation to pay Birds Electro-Mechanical the amounts that SEG was, otherwise, required to pay. It was in the interests of RAK Properties for the work to be completed. It was not in the interests of Birds Electro-Mechanical to complete the work if it was not being paid to do so.

30.         Birds Electro-Mechanical completed the works required of it under the Subcontracting Agreement. Following substantial completion, the site was handed back to SEG and RAK Properties. Arkonsult issued a Preliminary Access Certificate on 22 July 2022, confirming completion of the works. Birds Electro-Mechanical alleges that it is owed AED 2,887,861, a figure supported by statements of account rendered by both SEG and RAK Properties.

(d)           Analysis

31.         Although the present proceeding was not filed until 5 February 2026, RAK Properties was well aware of the basis for it and the amount claimed at a significantly earlier time. That is because Birds Electro-Mechanical had, originally, made its claim before the onshore Abu Dhabi Courts.

32.         In a judgment given on 27 February 2024, the Court of First Instance of the Abu Dhabi Commercial Court entered judgment against both SEG and RAK Properties for the amount claimed in this proceeding, AED 2,887,861. It did so on the basis of an expert report that it had directed after the onshore proceeding had been commenced. Subsequently, on 24 April 2024, the onshore Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by RAK Properties and annulled the First Instance judgment. It did so on jurisdictional grounds, holding that the dispute should be heard and determined by the ADGM Courts. The onshore Court of Appeal did not pronounce on the merits of the claim. [32]

33.         The importance of RAK Properties' prior knowledge of the Claim lies in the facts narrated in the expert report prepared for the Court of First Instance and in that Court's findings of fact. While there is no doubt that the factual findings made in the onshore courts are not binding on me, in the context of an application in which I am required to consider whether RAK Properties has a real prospect of successfully defending the Claim, undisputed facts identified from those sources are relevant.

34.         The last two payments received by Birds Electro-Mechanical were paid directly by RAK Properties on 7 October 2020 and 4 February 2021. Those payments represented moneys then owing to Birds Electro-Mechanical for services under the Subcontracting Agreement which, contractually, it was the obligation of SEG to pay. That suggests it is more likely than not that the Direct Payment NOC was executed on 19 April 2021 to formalise the parties' intention that RAK Properties would continue to make such payments to ensure that Birds Electro-Mechanical completed its work on the project. In addition, the intention of the Direct Payment NOC was confirmed in letters sent by SEG to Arkonsult and by Arkonsult to RAK Properties respectively on 28 April 2022. By that time, moneys outstanding to subcontractors had been identified. Arkonsult was passing on the details of the payment obligations to RAK Properties.

35.         While I agree with RAK Properties that it has no direct contractual obligation to pay the judgment sum to Birds Electro-Mechanical (on the grounds that it was not a party to the Subcontracting Agreement), I am not persuaded that RAK Properties has a real prospect of defending Birds Electro-Mechanical's claim. My reasons for so concluding are summarised briefly below:

a.             On the totality of the evidence before me, there is no basis on which Arkonsult would have needed to execute the Direct Payment NOC on its own behalf. Despite RAK Properties' assertions to the contrary, given that the Direct Payment NOC contemplates that Birds Electro-Mechanical will be paid to complete contracted works by RAK Properties, it is more likely than not that Arkonsult signed the document as an agent for RAK Properties. Put another way, RAK Properties has not persuaded me that there is a real prospect that, after trial, a finding would be made that Arkonsult signed the Direct Payment NOC on its own behalf. [33] Arkonsult's signature can be seen as RAK Properties' approval of the arrangement.

b.             There was no reason for Birds Electro-Mechanical to continue with work without an assurance of payment from RAK Properties. On the other hand, there was every incentive on RAK Properties to ensure that Birds Electro-Mechanical completed the work notwithstanding concerns about SEG's liquidity.

c.             As a matter of law, there are (at least) two bases on which Birds Electro-Mechanical's Claim can be sustained as a matter of English common law: [34]

                                       i.               The first is on the basis of assumption of liability. English common law recognises that a non-party to a contract may nevertheless assume an enforceable obligation to perform something that it is not contractually required to do. The underlying principle can be traced back to what was said by the House of Lords in Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd. [35] The reference in Hedley Byrne to a "voluntary" assumption of liability [36] does not require proof of an express consent. As Carr LJ (with whom King and Popplewell LJJ agreed on this point) said in Spire Property Development LLP v Withers LLP: [37] "..., the doing of the act implies a voluntary undertaking to assume responsibility."

                                     ii.               The second is based on a collateral contract, arising out of a combination of written evidence, oral statements and the parties' conduct. On this thesis, RAK Properties would have entered into a separate contractual arrangement whereby, in consideration of Birds Electro-Mechanical agreeing to complete necessary works for the project, RAK Properties would pay for the cost of doing so. Plainly, the Direct Payment NOC contemplated that both the scope of work and those payments would be based on those for which Birds Electro-Mechanical had contracted under the Subcontracting Agreement. [38]

36.         In light of the circumstances to which I have referred and the underlying legal principles, I am not persuaded that RAK Properties has demonstrated that it has a "real prospect" of successfully defending the proceeding. The Merits Issue must be determined in favour of Birds Electro-Mechanical.

Result

37.         For the reasons given:

a.             The Set Aside Application is dismissed.

b.             Costs are awarded in favour of Birds Electro-Mechanical on the standard basis to be determined on a summary basis if not agreed. The parties shall advise the Registry if agreement were not reached. On receipt of such notice, I will issue directions for the exchange of submissions on questions of costs (including statements of costs required under Practice Direction 9) and determine quantum on the papers.

 

Issued by:

 

Linda Fitz-Alan
Registrar, ADGM Courts

7 August 2026

 



[1] In some documents Société D,Entreprise & De Gestation Emirates Contracting LLC is described as "SEG Emirates Contracting LLC". As the correct name of that party is not material for the purpose of determining the present application, I have used the descriptor "SEG" throughout this judgment.

[2] ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016, rule 15(2).

[3] Ibid, rule 22.

[4] Judgment was entered under rule 39 of the ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016.

[5] Order dated 25 March 2026, at paragraphs 2, 4 and 6.

[6] Order dated 17 April 2026.

[7] ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016, rules 15(1), (2) and (3)(c), 16A and 16B(1) and (3)(a) and (b). See also Part C of Practice Direction 6, which sets out the requirements for service on a company, by reference to rule 16A of the Rules. The Service Issue is discussed at paragraphs 6–16 below.

[8] Ibid, rule 41(2)(a). The Merits Issue is discussed at paragraphs 17–35 below.

[9] Order of 25 March 2026, at paragraph 3.

[10] ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016, rule 18(c).

[11] See paragraph 10 below.

[12] ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016, rule 16B(3)(a) and (b), set out at paragraph 9 above.

[13] Ibid, rule 18(c). See also paragraph 7 above.

[14] ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016, rule 16B(3)(a) and (b).

[15] Al Khaleej Investment PSC v Ocean Pearl Real Estate Comp LLC [2025] ADGMCFI 0012, at paragraph 14.

[16] See paragraphs 8 and 12 of Mathew 1, set out at paragraph 8 above.

[17] See paragraph 10 above.

[18] Al Khaleej Investment PSC v Ocean Pearl Real Estate Comp LLC [2025] ADGMCFI 0012, at paragraphs 19 and 20.

[19] See paragraphs 17–22 below.

[20] Laktineh & Co Ltd v Ahmed Al Hatta [2020] ADGMCFI 0001.

[21] Ibid, at paragraph 12.

[22] Ibid, at paragraph 40.

[23] See paragraph 9 of Mr Mathew's witness statement, set out at paragraph 8 above. On his evidence, RAK Properties first became aware of the existence of the proceedings when the Registry sent an email to it on 11 May 2026.

[24] ADGM Court Procedure Rules 2016, rule 41(2)(a).

[25] Ibid, rule 208(4).

[26] Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd v James Kemball Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 33, per Popplewell LJ. 

[27] Ibid, at paragraphs 17 and 18. 

[28] Union Properties PJSC v Trinkler and Partners Ltd [2024] ADGMCFI 0014, at paragraph 31.

[29] URS Corporation Ltd v BDW Trading Ltd [2023] EWCA Civ 772. 

[30] Ibid, at paragraphs 152 and 153.

[31] The relevant parts of the Direct Payment NOC are set out at paragraph 27 below.

[32] For completeness, I add that while the onshore proceedings were considered under UAE law, the parties agree that ADGM law applies on the present application.

[33] As to onus of proof, see paragraph 25 above.

[34] Applicable in the ADGM by reason of section 1(1) of the Application of English Law Regulations 2015.

[35] Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465. See also the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom's approval of the concept of assumption of responsibility in Playboy Club London Ltd & Ors v Banca Nazionale del Lavoro SpA [2018] UKSC 43at paragraphs 6-7.

[36] Ibid, at 529 and 530.

[37] Spire Property Development LLP v Withers LLP [2023] 4 WLR 56, at paragraph 59.

[38] See the terms of the Direct Payment NOC set out at paragraph 27 above.


BAILII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Donate to BAILII
URL: https://www.bailii.org/ae/cases/ADGMCFI/2026/23.html