![]() |
[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] [DONATE] | |
England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division) Decisions |
||
|
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division) Decisions >> NMUL Realisations Ltd, Re [2021] EWHC 94 (Ch) (20 January 2021) URL: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Ch/2021/94.html Cite as: [2021] EWHC 94 (Ch) |
||
[New search]
[Context
]
[View without highlighting]
[Printable PDF version]
[Help]
2021] EWHC 94 ( Ch) | ||
BUSINESS AND PROPERTY COURTS OF ENGLAND AND WALES
INSOLVENCY AND COMPANIES LIST (
ChD)
IN
THE MATTER OF NMUL REALISATIONS LIMITED
AND IN THE MATTER OF THE INSOLVENCY ACT 1986
The Royal Courts of Justice 7 Rolls Building, Fetter Lane London EC4A 1NL |
||
2021 |
B e f o r e :
____________________
| Lee Andrew Causer Danny Nicolaas William Dartnaill Ryan Kevin Grant (in their capacities as the joint administrators of NMUL Realisations Limited (in administration)) |
Applicants |
|
- and |
||
| NMUL Realisations Limited (in administration) |
Respondent |
____________________
The Respondent did not appear and was not represented.
Hearing date: 21 December 2020
____________________
Crown Copyright ©
2021.
Deputy Insolvency and Companies Court Judge Frith:
Introduction
charge
on behalf of the Company that created the
charge
to secure its borrowing in circumstances where in fact, at all material times, a substantial balance remained due. This resulted in a failure to give notice to the holder of a prior security pursuant to paragraph 15 of Schedule B1 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (the "Act").
charge
holder to give notice to a prior
chargee
of its intention to do so under the provisions of paragraph 15 of Schedule B1 of the Act. These are the reasons why I did so.
The Facts
cheat
the public revenue and sentenced to terms of imprisonment. On 29 September 2014, confiscation orders were made against them under the provisions of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. This course of events followed an investigation by the Pensions Regulator who, on 4 October 2011, gave notice that an order had been made to the effect that Tudor should be suspended from acting as a trustee in relation to trust schemes pursuant to section 4 of the Pensions Act 1995. The effect of such a notice was that Tudor was prohibited from exercising any functions as a trustee of the trust schemes. It is the understanding of the Applicants that these actions were prompted by the initiation of the criminal proceedings against Messrs Meeson and Bradley which ultimately resulted in their conviction, imprisonment and subsequently, the imposition of confiscation orders over their realisable property.
Chargor.
It is this notification that caused the circumstances giving rise to this application.
charge
showing on the Company's register as being unsatisfied was the Metro Debenture. Both the Santander Debenture and Tudor Debenture were shown as being satisfied in full.
charge
which ranked in priority to the Metro Debenture. Consequently, notice of an intention to appoint should have been served pursuant to paragraph 15 of Schedule B1 of the Act. Whilst the
checks
were made with Santander in relation to any security it held over NMHL and its subsidiary due to the fact that its
charge
was noted as being unsatisfied in the register, no such
checks
were made in respect of the Company as to the existence of any continuing debt secured by the Tudor Debenture.
" any property in which the Defendant has any interest or to which the Defendant has any right and any property held by any other person to whom the Defendant has made a gift caught by the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, including but not limited to all property set or in the Schedules below."
There was only one asset specifically defined in the schedule to the ERO which provided as follows:
"1) The outstanding value of the loan under the original loan agreement plus interest owed to [Tudor] as the trustee of [MSIPP] by [the Company]. The whole amount should be attributed to both Peter Bradley and Andrew Meeson."
"I note from the enforcement receivership orders dated the 6th of September 2019 that the beneficial assets of [Tudor] and [MSIPP] are to be treated as the personal assets of Peter Bradley and Andrew Meeson. I also note that the schedules to those orders state that the benefit of the loan made by [Tudor] (as trustee of [MSIPP] to [the Company] shall be attributed to those two individuals."
Having come to that conclusion, the GLD was therefore satisfied that the beneficial assets of Tudor did not vest in the Crown as bona vacantia, but instead formed part of the realisable property of Messrs Meeson and Bradley. In fact, the claim of the Enforcement Receiver had been accepted by the Applicants prior to the receipt of this response and the sum claimed was paid on 20 November 2020. It follows that from the date of her appointment as the Enforcement Receiver, the beneficial interest in the MSIPP loan and the MSIPP debenture formed part of the realisable assets of Messrs Meeson and Bradley which could be realised by the Enforcement Receiver for the purpose of discharging the confiscation orders that had been made against them.
The status of the notice of satisfaction filed by the Company
charge
is very limited indeed. In short, if a certificate of satisfaction is filed pursuant to section 859L, then by section 859L (5) the Registrar of Companies must include a statement of satisfaction in the Register.
"Section 859L makes provision for the filing of specified particulars and a statement to the effect that either the debt for which thecharge
has been given has been paid or satisfied in whole or in part or that all or part of the property or undertaking
charged
by the registered
charge
has been released from the
charge
or has ceased to form part of the company's property or undertaking. If such a statement and the relevant particulars are filed using Companies Form MR04 or MR05 respectively, section 859L (5) obliges the Registrar to include a statement of satisfaction or release as the case may be, in the Register."
"The Registrar may, on receipt of a verifying statement in the prescribed form, enter a memorandum of satisfaction or release. A memorandum of satisfaction records either the partial or complete payment of thecharged
debt. A memorandum of release records either the partial or complete release of the
charged
property or it ceasing to belong to the company, as the case may be. The Registrar's entry is not, however, conclusive since the statement delivered may be fraudulent. In this case those making it will be guilty of perjury but a subsequent
charge
relying on it will be postponed. Prospective
chargees
should therefore always seek evidence that prior
chargees
have released their security rather than rely upon searches at Companies House. Section 874 does not state who is entitled to apply for the memorandum and it should be amended to require the memorandum to be filed by the
charge."
Charges
(2nd edition, 1996) the position is "
the Registrar accepts as sufficient evidence of satisfaction of a
charge
the statement of the
chargor
itself, without any statement from the
chargee.
If a discharge were wrongly registered through a false statement of the
chargor,
the
chargee
cannot lose the benefit of its security. Equally a prospective creditor cannot rely on the memorandum of discharge on the Register. In strict theory, a subsequent creditor must satisfy himself from his own enquiries as to the effective discharge of the previously registered
charges.
The Registrar's certificate of
charge
is conclusive in its effect. By contrast, the copy of the memorandum as to the entry of a memorandum of discharge which the Registrar can give to the company, or a certified copy to any person, is not conclusive in its effect."
charge.
(See Andrew Fender (administrator of FG Collier & Sons Limited) v- National Westminster Bank plc [2008]
EWHC
2242 (
Ch))
and Lehman Brothers Australia Limited v- MacNamara & Others [2020] EWCA Civ 321 and the unreported decision of HHJ Langan in Re OC Realisations 2011 (in liquidation)).
charge
and debt that it secured and the liability of the Company to pay it. It does not affect in any way the obligation to give the holder of such a prior
charge
the appropriate notice under paragraph 15 of Schedule B1 of the Act, but to whom should such notice have been given? Mr Sims QC invited me to find that in reality there was no one to whom such notice could have been given following the dissolution of Tudor. That in my view is taking the effect of the dissolution too far. The authorities confirm that the liability continues notwithstanding the dissolution of Tudor and so does the security interest. The Registrar of Companies has the obligation to register the notice in the manner indicated above, but it is well known that this is not determinative of the issue of the underlying liability.
charges
to gain either their consent to the dispensation of service or their consent to the appointment, just as Metro contacted Santander in relation to its security over the assets of NMHL. The Applicants' factual case is that at the time of their appointment, neither Metro nor the proposed administrators knew of the existence of the Tudor or of the appointment of the Enforcement Receiver. If they had been aware of these two factual elements, they may have been able to give notice either to the Crown bona vacantia or to the Enforcement Receiver in respect of the Tudor Debenture. However, even this may not have obviated the need for directions in any event, because it is still a matter of some conjecture as to whether they fall into the definition of the holder of a qualifying floating
charge
to whom notice can be given. Whilst the effect of an enforcement receivership order does not vest the assets beneficially in the Enforcement Receiver, the view taken by the GLD on behalf of the Crown bona vacantia suggests that "the benefit of the loan made by [Tudor] (as trustee of [MSIPP] to [the Company] shall be attributed to [the Enforcement Receiver]." This does not make it clear that, in addition to having the benefit of the loan in the sense of applying the proceeds of repayment against the liability of the confiscation order the legal interest of the Tudor Debenture was effectively transferred from the GLD on behalf of the Crown bona vacantia (where it had been held since the date of Tudor's dissolution) to the Enforcement Receiver. It is certainly arguable that it did not.
What are the consequences of a failure to give notice under paragraph 15?
"(1) a person may not appoint and administrator under paragraph 14 unless
(a) he has given at least two business days' written notice to the holder of any prior floatingcharge
which satisfies paragraph 14(2), or
(b) the holder of any prior floatingcharge
which satisfies paragraph 14(2) has consented in writing to the making of the appointment.
(2) One floatingcharge
is prior to another for the purposes of this paragraph if
(a) it was created first, or
(b) it is to be treated as having priority in accordance with an agreement to which the holder of each floatingcharge
was a party "
"For the purpose of sub-paragraph (1) a floatingcharge
qualifies if created by an instrument which
(a) states that this paragraph applies to the floatingcharge,
(b) purports to empower the holder of a floatingcharge
to appoint an administrator of the company,
(c) purports to empower the holder of the floatingcharge
to make an appointment which would be the appointment of an administrative receiver within the meaning given by section 29(2), or "
EWHC
1133 (
Ch)
and the decision of ICC Judge Jones in Re Tokenhouse [2020]
EWHC
3171 (
Ch).
Both these cases involved a comprehensive and impressive review of the authorities from which Mr Sims QC extrapolated the following principles.
EWHC
2356 (
Ch).
In that case the defect considered was a failure to comply with paragraph 28 of Schedule B1 of the Act. In construing the effects of such a failure to comply with that provision the judge approached the issue as follows:
"[17] I propose to adopt the approach taken by HHJ McCahill QC in Hill v Stokes [2010]EWHC
3726 (
Ch)
at paragraphs [63] [67], by HHJ Purle QC in Re Assured Logistics Solutions Ltd [2011]
EWHC
3029 (
Ch)
at paragraph [33], and which I followed in Re Bezier Acquisitions Limited [2011]
EWHC
3299 and Re Virtualpurple (supra) (which themselves have been followed by Arnold J in Re Ceart Risk Services [2012]
EWHC
1178 and HHJ Purle QC in Re BXL Services [2012]
EWHC
1877 (
Ch)).
This is to focus on the consequences of non-compliance and, taking into account those consequences, to consider whether Parliament intended the outcome of non-compliance to be total invalidity: in short, to ask whether it was a purpose of the legislation that an appointment made in breach of paragraph 28 should be null."
At paragraph 26 he went on to say:
"[26] " in my judgment considerable weight should be given to the consideration that the object of introducing out-of-court appointments was to streamline the process of business rescue: I adhere to the view which I expressed in Re Virtualpurple Professional Services Ltd that it is highly undesirable to have a multiplicity of circumstances in which the appointment of an administrator is automatically invalidated."
At paragraph 28 he stated:
"[28] I consider that this distinction is reflected in the terms of Schedule B1 itself as regards appointments by directors. Paragraphs 22 to 25 inclusive specify when it is that the directors or the company have the power to appoint administrators. Paragraphs 26 to 32 set out the procedural requirements for the exercise of the power. The structure of the Schedule suggests (albeit not strongly) that the Court should treat non-compliance with the requirements set out in paragraph 28 as leading to an irregularity rather than the nullity.
EWHC
2607. When considering the approach to be adopted in curing a defect he sought to categorise potentially defective appointments into three categories as follows:
[21] "Defective out-of-court administration appointments can be divided into three categories:
(1) Cases where the defect is fundamental. In such cases, the purported administration appointment is a nullity. There are no insolvency proceedings on foot, and so there is nothing that the court can cure.
(2) Cases where the defect is not fundamental and causes no substantial injustice. Rule 12.64 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 provides: "No insolvency proceedings will be invalidated by any formal defect or any irregularity unless the court before which objection is made considers that substantial injustice has been caused by the defect or irregularity and that the injustice cannot be remedied by any order of the court." Thus, provided the defect is not fundamental (i.e. not falling within paragraph 21(1) above), so that there are indeed insolvency proceedings on foot, the court must first satisfy itself that the defect or irregularity has caused no "substantial injustice". If so satisfied, then the proceedings will not be invalidated by any formal defect or irregularity.
(3) Cases where the defect is not fundamental, but substantial injustice is caused. If the defect again, not being a fundamental defect within paragraph 21(1) above is found to cause "substantial injustice", then the court must ask itself whether that substantial injustice can be remedied by an order of the court. Of course, the court will consider, in light of all the circumstances, whether it is appropriate to make a remedial order. If so, then the defect is cured on the court making the order. If the court cannot make a remedial order or does not consider that it is appropriate to do so, then the defect remains uncured."
charge
itself is not enforceable, or there is already in office a provisional liquidator).
charge
holder's control.
charge
holders will be treated as an irregularity, and as such, it will prima facie fall within the second category described by Marcus Smith J in Skeggs Beef Limited.
[28] "If one asks the question whether Parliament can fairly be intended to have to have intended that an appointment made in breach of this provision should be invalid, in my view the answer is that Parliament can be taken to have intended that because it is consistent with the purpose of the provision that prior notice should be given in order that the firstcharge
holder may act before the second
charge
holder does."
[28] "[the decision in Euromaster] supersedes the approach in Re Eco Link Resources Ltd (In CVL) The First Issue [as the effect of a failure to give notice in accordance with the Rules] should be determined on the basis that paragraphs 26-32 of Schedule B1 prescribe procedural requirements with the result that a breach will "naturally fall to be treated as irregular". It is also highly significant that Sir Terence Etherton whenChancellor
approved Mr Justice Norris's reasoning [in Euromaster] in the case of Re Melodious Corporation , albeit in the context of Rule 7.55 of the Insolvency Rules 1986 (now Rule 12.65 of the Insolvency Rules 2016) (see paragraphs [73 and 75] of the judgment)."
choice. It does not in and of itself give a senior creditor the ability to block the appointment of administrators.
Disposal