![]() |
[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] [DONATE] | |
England and Wales High Court (Commercial Court) Decisions |
||
|
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> England and Wales High Court (Commercial Court) Decisions >> Trafigura Beheer BV & Anor v Mediterranean Shipping Company SA [2007] EWHC 944 (Comm) (26 April 2007) URL: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2007/944.html Cite as: [2007] EWHC 944 (Comm) |
||
[New search]
[Context
]
[View without highlighting]
[Printable RTF version]
[Help]
QUEEN'S BENCH DIVISION
COMMERCIAL COURT
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL |
||
B e f o r e :
____________________
(1) TRAFIGURA BEHEER BV and (2) HMC COMPANY LIMITED |
Claimant |
|
| - and - |
||
| MEDITERRANEAN SHIPPING COMPANY SA |
Defendant |
____________________
Mr Luke Parsons QC and Mr Chirag Karia (instructed by Hill Dickinson LLP) for the Defendant
Hearing dates: 19th, 20th, 21st, 22nd, February 2007
____________________
Crown Copyright ©
Mr Justice Aikens :
A. Outline of the case
B. The facts leading to the conversion of the containers
Trafigura
Beheer BV Amsterdam office ("
Trafigura")
on FOB terms, under a Memorandum of Agreement between Rustenburg and
Trafigura
dated 2` February 2005. By this contract, which was effective as from 1 January 2005,
Trafigura
agreed to purchase 6000 tonnes of copper cathodes from Rustenburg during the period 1 January to 31 December 2005. The purchases were to be in 500 ton lots per month, all FOB Durban, South Africa.
Trafigura
(as FOB buyers) through its shipping agents/freight forwarders on about 29 August 2005.[2] So
Trafigura
was the real shipper and was a party to the contract of carriage with the shipowner evidenced by the bill of lading. The bill of lading was made out "To Order" and the "notify party" was identified as C Steinweg Warehousing (FE) Pte Ltd, Shanghai. That company is the Chinese subsidiary of one of the world's largest LME[3] warehousing companies. Shanghai was named as the discharge port in the bill of lading.
Trafigura
had sold the cargo to Shanghai HMC Company Limited ("HMC"), the second claimant, which is a company incorporated in the People's Republic of China ("PRC"). HMC is wholly owned by persons affiliated to
Trafigura.
The sale contract, dated 19 October 2005,[4] was for the sale of 360 tonnes of "Off – grade Amplates Copper metals" on "CIF Liner Terms" Shanghai. The price of this CIF sale was not fixed at the time of the sale contract. The contractual terms for calculating the price of the cargo are complex. I will set them out below. They may have to be considered in detail in relation to part of the Claimants' claim for damages. In the event,
Trafigura
has not yet been paid by HMC for the cargo.
Trafigura's)
agents, who were Windward Shipping (Pty) Ltd. The bill itself was generated when the information was put onto a "template" bill of lading displayed on a computer screen. The first and genuine bill of lading, which has the number MSCUDN 065539, was signed by an authorised employee of MSC South Africa, as agent for the Master.[5] The "set" of three original and genuine bills of lading was released to Rustenburg (supposedly as "shipper") in early October 2005, against payment of the freight. That totalled US$6,570 for the 18 containers. In evidence, Mr Richard Tildesley (
Trafigura's
Risk Manager) accepted that it was not the habit of
Trafigura
to declare to a shipowner the value of copper shipped in containers.[6] Nor did
Trafigura
expect the value of the copper to be declared on the bills of lading.[7] Neither was done in this case. However, it was
Trafigura's
practice to notify the sale invoice value of the cargo to its cargo insurers when the cargo is declared to them.[8]
Trafigura
paid Rustenburg's invoice for the cargo on 12 October 2005. The invoice price was US$1,399,396.69. When
Trafigura
paid Rustenburg for the cargo, the three original bills of lading which had been issued to Rustenburg were endorsed by it and the set of three was sent to
Trafigura,
via
Trafigura's
shipping agents, ACS.
Trafigura/HMC
nor Ningbo produced a bill of lading to obtain discharge of the containers into the container yard. Although Ningbo obtained the DO from Sino – Agent in return for the surrender of the fraudulent bill of lading, thus entitling Ningbo to obtain custody of the containers from the container yard, Ningbo has never been able to do so. This is because of Sino – Agent's "Work – Coordination Note", which was sent to the container terminal SECT, on the instructions of MSC. Therefore, from that time onwards, the only party that had effective control over the movement of the containers has been MSC.
Trafigura
and HMC applied to the Shanghai Maritime Court for an order for the release of the cargo to them. On 4 November 2005 the court made an order that MSC deliver up the cargo to HMC immediately. Eventually, on 10 November, MSC issued a second DO in favour of HMC. This second DO stated: "…This delivery order shall only be valid with both the ship agent and Customs releasing stamp…". HMC's customs clearance agent, Changshen, presented this second DO to the customs authority to obtain its releasing stamp. The customs authority refused to stamp the new DO, because clearance for Ningbo had already been granted.
C. "Hedging"
Trafigura
purchase of copper from Rustenburg, the quotational period for the purchase price agreed between the parties was the month of shipment of the copper. When a trader sells - on the physical metal it has bought, the sale price will also usually be fixed by reference to the LME price for a fixed quotational period at a certain point in the future (usually around the estimated delivery date), plus a premium.[17]
Trafigura
and HMC habitually hedged all their trades in metals against movements in the LME price, so as not to be exposed to the type of fluctuations in price I have described. I accept that hedging is common practice amongst metal traders. The extent to which shipowners may be aware generally of the extent and practice of hedging by metal traders who ship cargo in containers on board container carriers is a different matter. So also is the question of whether MSC were ever aware of the likelihood of the claimants engaging in hedging activities, either in relation to this particular cargo, or as part of a general "book" of copper purchases and sales. If necessary I shall return to those two issues later in this judgment.
Trafigura
has purchased and the price obtained by
Trafigura
on a sale to a customer (in this case HMC),
Trafigura
makes a "hedge" by selling forward an equivalent amount of metal to that purchased. But because
Trafigura
has a great many purchase and sale contracts, it does not try to match particular purchases with particular forward, hedge, sale contracts. Instead,
Trafigura
maintains a "Base Metals Unpriced Contracts Report". Maintenance of this report was one of Mr Tildesley's responsibilities. The report sets out all the sales and purchases made by
Trafigura's
traders in LME copper cathodes in a particular month. The report is actually divided into three parts. The first part sets out contracts where the price of the sale or purchase is not yet known. The second part sets out those contracts where the price of the sale or purchase is by reference to an average monthly LME cash settlement price for that month. The third part sets out those contracts that are priced on a partial average for that particular month.
Trafigura
does not enter into hedging contracts itself. Its hedging arrangements are made through
Trafigura
Derivatives Limited ("TDL"), which is a wholly owned subsidiary of
Trafigura
and which has a separate "profit centre". TDL carries out the hedging requirements of all entities in the
Trafigura
group. TDL will net off any compatible hedging requests that are received from all the entities in the
Trafigura
group and then go into the LME market and make net forward sales or purchases as need be. Then TDL will attribute to particular
Trafigura
entities the forward sale or purchase price as appropriate, so that an entity (such as
Trafigura
itself) can work out whether it will make a profit or loss on the copper cathode trading of that particular month.
Trafigura
normally priced a sale contract for physical copper by reference to a "quotational period" around the anticipated date of delivery of the physical goods. In the sale contract with HMC, the sale price provisions were:
"3. Price
Any unknown LME Copper Seller's quotation during the Quotational Period adjusted at market to prompt date of 16 November 2005 plus a flat premium of US$0.00 (Zero) per Metric Tonne.
4. Quotational Period.
4.1 The Buyer has the right to price on any LME working day or days starting from the contract being signed until 16 November 2005.
The Q/P may be extended by mutual agreement between Seller and Buyer.
Should Buyer not have price fixed the contractual tonnage prior by 11.30 AM London time on 16 November 2005 and no Q/P extenson has been agreed as per above mentioned QP extension clause, then any remaining unpriced quantity shall be automatically price fixed basis the LME Official Copper Settlement Quotation of 16 November 2005…."
Trafigura
has never been in a position to deliver the physical copper to HMC, HMC has been unable to find a buyer in China, because a PRC buyer would only be interested if the copper could be physically delivered. So the two parties to the sale contract (ie.
Trafigura
and HMC) have agreed that it should not be priced. HMC and
Trafigura
have, effectively, agreed to vary the sale contract terms as set out above. The effect of this is that
Trafigura
has not been able to take the Rustenburg/
Trafigura
purchase contract out of the account for the purposes of calculating the September 2005
Trafigura
overall hedging requirements.
Trafigura
having to "keep open" the hedge position so far as the Rustenburg/
Trafigura
purchase contract is concerned,
Trafigura
has incurred costs at the end of each three month period, because the "open" hedge position has had to be rolled over after each period. These costs are called "rollover" costs or, sometimes (and confusingly), "backwardation" costs. Mr Tildesley was content to use another, generic, term for these costs, which he called "spread costs"[19] A figure for the total of these costs, which
Trafigura
says are attributable to the Rustenburg/
Trafigura
purchase contract and its associated hedges, is agreed at US$154,343.72.
Trafigura
says that these "backwardation" or "spread" costs constitute the difference in the price of the LME copper that is "borrowed" in order to close out and roll over a hedge position.[20] So, if there had been a hedge by way of a forward sale for the period 1 November to 1 February, and the hedge is to be kept open, then at the end of the three month period (ie. 1February), that forward sale will be matched by a forward purchase (using "borrowed" LME copper), at the prevailing spot price on 1 February. The forward sale hedge is then "rolled over" into the next 3 month period, from 1 February to 1 May. However, Mr Tildesley accepted in cross – examination that the "borrowing loss" figures[21] formed part of an internal record and calculation within
Trafigura.
It did not represent a sum that
Trafigura
had had to pay to TDL in order to hedge the Rustenburg/
Trafigura
purchase contract. MSC submits that
Trafigura
has failed to prove that any of these costs have actually been incurred.
Trafigura
also claims that because the notional forward hedge sale in respect of the Rustenburg/
Trafigura
purchase contract has never been "closed out", there is a danger of a final "hedging loss". Whether there is a "hedging loss" and how much it will be is dependent upon two things. First, the date and secondly the price at which the sale of the physical copper from
Trafigura
to HMC is fixed.[22] However, Mr Tildesley accepted that when a hedge is "closed out" by TDL, it does not close out a specific futures contract that matches a particular physical contract. All that happens is that a particular physical contract is priced and the hedge requirements of the
Trafigura
group is adjusted accordingly.[23]
D. The Bill of Lading Terms
Trafigura
were actually the shippers of the cargo as the FOB buyers from Rustenburg and the CIF sellers to HMC. It is also agreed that the terms of the contract of carriage between
Trafigura
and MSC are contained in the bill of lading terms set out on the face and the reverse of the genuine bill of lading. It is further agreed that because HMC has never paid
Trafigura
for the goods, then
Trafigura
remains the owner of the cargo and therefore has title to sue. Accordingly, I will refer to
Trafigura
hereafter, rather than "the Claimants".
"IN ACCEPTING this Bol the Merchant expressly agrees to be bound by all the terms, conditions, limitations and exceptions, whether printed, stamped or written hereon and page 1…
IN WITNESS wherof the no. of Original Bills of Lading shown at the top right corner of this contract have been signed. If this is negotiable (To Order) Bol the goods will only be delivered if one original Bol, properly endorsed by the shippers and/or the Bank concerned (and not by the Notify Party) is surrendered the others being considered null and void".
E. The arguments of the parties
Trafigura
is that the shipowner was guilty of converting the cargo in two ways. First, the shipowner interfered with the title of
Trafigura
by the action of Sino – Agent (agents for MSC, the shipowner) in giving Ningbo a DO in return for a fraudulent bill of lading. Secondly, MSC interfered with the title of
Trafigura
to the goods by the action of its agent, Sino – Agent, in failing to delivery up the cargo to
Trafigura,
despite the presentation of the genuine bill of lading to Sino – Agent, on 25 October 2005. Other causes of action in tort that might be available to
Trafigura
were pleaded, but they were not specifically pursued at the trial.
Trafigura
could maintain the same claims, but put as breaches by MSC of the contract of carriage contained in the bill of lading. Other potential breach of contract claims had also been pleaded. None of these were specifically pursued at the trial.
Trafigura
as a consequence of MSC's conversion of the cargo. MSC relies on the terms of the bill of lading and claims that they provide it with complete protection from any monetary liability to
Trafigura.
Alternatively, MSC says that its monetary liability is very limited.
Trafigura)
; and if so, which set of terms apply and to which period?
Trafigura
is entitled to damages for conversion. If there is no limitation of liability involved, then the normal measure of damages is the value of the goods at the time of conversion, plus any consequential losses that are not too remote in law.
Trafigura
owns the goods, it was reasonable to continue the hedge arrangements. Indeed, MSC, through its solicitors, encouraged
Trafigura
to continue the hedging arrangements so as to limit any potential losses. Awarding damages equal to the current value of the cargo would mean that
Trafigura
would recover some or all of its hedging losses. Thirdly, if MSC has to pay damages for conversion equal to the value of the goods, then it will be entitled to take the cargo. It would be unjust if MSC could take the cargo with its current (higher) value but only pay damages equal to its value in 2005.
Trafigura
is only entitled to obtain damages equal to the value of the cargo at the date of conversion, then it is entitled to recover
Trafigura's
hedging losses either as consequential losses or as "mitigation losses". The hedging position that
Trafigura
had to take and the hedging orders it had to give to TDL were caused, in part, by the fact that the sale to HMC could never be priced.
Trafigura's
hedging arrangements at the time that the contract of carriage was concluded. Further,
Trafigura
cannot demonstrate that the hedging losses were what everyone will know will arise in the majority of cases where there has been conversion of a cargo of copper in containers. Mr Parsons submits that the hedging losses were caused by
Trafigura's
decision to agree with HMC to vary the sale contract, so as to continue to keep the cargo unpriced past the latest contract date of 16 November 2005 and
Trafigura's
decision to maintain the hedge position. Therefore, assuming all the other defences of MSC fail, MSC's liability is limited to the value of the cargo on 24 October 2005 ie. US$1,445,498,96.
F. The Issues for Decision.
(1) On the true construction of clause 1(a) of the bill of lading terms, do the HR or the HVR apply to the bill of lading contract? If the HVR apply do they do so by contract or the force of law?[31]
(2) On the true construction of the bill of lading terms, in particular clauses 4, 7 and 22, do the HR or the HVR apply to the period after the cargo had been discharged from the ship but whilst the containers remained in the container terminal to the order of MSC ("the post – discharge period")?
(3) If the HR, alternatively HVR, do apply to the post – discharge period, then, on the true construction of Article IV(5) of the HR or the HVR (whichever is applicable), is MSC entitled to limit its monetary liability for conversion of the cargo during the post – discharge period? If so, to what amount?
(4) If the HR, alternatively HVR, do not apply to the post – discharge period, then does clause 22 exclude or limit any monetary liability of MSC if it converts the cargo during the post – discharge period?
(5) If the HR, alternatively HVR, do not apply to the post – discharge period and MSC cannot exclude or limit its monetary liability for conversion of the cargo by virtue of the terms of the bill of lading, then what is the proper measure of damages for conversion of the cargo by MSC on the facts of this case? In particular: (a) is
Trafigura
entitled to claim damages based on the value of the cargo at the time of judgment or is that claim limited to the value of the cargo at the time of conversion (ie. 24 or 25 October 2005); and (b) is
Trafigura
entitled to recover, in addition to the value of the cargo, any of its "hedging losses"?
Trafigura,
as owner of the cargo, and MSC as the carrier of the cargo, is governed by the bill of lading terms. This must be so given the terms on the face of the bill of lading that I have set out at paragraph 43 above.
Trafigura
was the bailor. Fifthly, this bailment was a contractual bailment on terms, which are those contained in the bill of lading.
"First, the defendant's conduct was inconsistent with the rights of the owner (or other person entitled to possession). Second, the conduct was deliberate, not accidental. Third, the conduct was so extensive an encroachment on the rights of the owner as to exclude him from use and possession of the goods. The contrast is with lesser acts of interference. If these cause damage they may give rise to claims for trespass or in negligence, but they do not constitute conversion".
Trafigura,
as owner of the cargo and clearly satisfies all of Lord Nicholls' requirements. Mr Parsons accepted this was so. In my view it is also plain that the failure of MSC to give
Trafigura/HMC
a DO on the following day also fulfilled all Lord Nicholls' requirements. Despite the order of MSC to the container terminal not to release the containers except on MSC's instructions, the consequences of MSC's earlier conduct is that
Trafigura
and HMC are excluded from the use and possession of the goods, although it is still possible that they might regain it at some stage in the future.
G. Issue One: On the true construction of clause 1(a) of the bill of lading terms, do the Hague Rules or the Hague Visby Rules apply to the bill of lading contract? If the latter apply, do they do so by contract or the force of law?
"This B/L shall have effect as follows:
(a) For all trades, except for goods shipped to and from the United States of America, this B/L shall be subject to the 1924 Hague Rules with the express exclusion of Article IX, or, if compulsorily applicable, subject to the 1968 Protocol (Hague – Visby) or any compulsory legislation based on the Hague Rules and/or the said Protocols. Where Hague – Visby or similar legislation is compulsorily applicable, the Hague – Visby 1979 Protocol ("SDR" Protocol) shall also apply whether or not mandatory".
"1.(1) In this Act, "the Rules" means the International Convention of certain rules of law relating to bills of lading signed at Brussels on 25 August 1924, as amended by the Protocol signed at Brussels on 23 February 1968 and by the Protocol signed at Brussels on 21 December 1979.
(2) The provisions of the Rules, as set out in the Schedule to this Act, shall have the force of law.
…….
(6) Without prejudice to Article X(c) of the Rules, the Rules shall have the force of law in relation to –
(a) any bill of lading if the contract contained in or evidenced by it expressly provides that the Rules shall govern the contract,
………..
Schedule. The Hague Rules as amended by the Brussels Protocol 1968.
…………..
Article X
The provisions of these Rules shall apply to every bill of lading relating to the carriage of goods between ports in two different States if
(a) the bill of lading is issued in a Contracting State; [42] or
(b) the carriage is from a Contracting State; or
(c) the contract contained in or evidenced by the bill of lading provides that these Rules or legislation of any State giving effect to them are to govern the contract
whatever may be the nationality of the ship, the carrier, the shipper, the consignee, or any other interested person."
"The Hague – Visby Rules, or rather all those of them that are in the Schedule [to the Act] are to have the force of law in the United Kingdom: they are to be treated as if they were part of directly enacted statute law".
Lord Diplock went on to say that an English court must give the provisions of the HVR, as set out in the Schedule, a "purposive rather than a narrow literalistic construction".
"1. Application of Hague Rules. – (1) Those Rules contained in the International Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules of Law Relating to Bills of Lading signed at Brussels on 25 August 1924, as amended by the Protocol signed at Brussels on 23 February 1968, which are set out in the Schedule (hereinafter referred to as the Rules) shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, have the force of law and apply in respect of the Republic in relation to and in connection with –
(a) the carriage of goods by sea in ships where the port of shipment is a port in the Republic, whether or not the carriage is between ports in two different States within the meaning of Article X of the Rules;
(b) any bill of lading if the contract contained in or evidenced by it expressly provides that the Rules shall govern the contract".
It is thus clear (and was not in dispute) that the South African Act is legislation that comes within the wording of Article X(c) of the HVR as being "…legislation of any State giving effect to …" the HVR. It must also be clear that, at least as a matter of South African law, this legislation is compulsorily applicable to contracts of carriage where the port of shipment is in South Africa, as it was in this case.
H. Issue Two: On the true construction of the bill of lading terms, in particular clauses 4, 7 and 22, do [the HR or] the HVR apply to the period after the cargo had been discharged from the ship but whilst the containers remained in the container terminal to the order of MSC ("the post – discharge period").
"Article I(e). Carriage of goods covers the period from the time when the goods are loaded on to the time when they are discharged from the ship"
"Article II. Subject to the provisions of Article VI, under every contract of carriage of goods by sea the carrier in relation to the loading , handling, stowage, carriage, custody, care and discharge of such goods, shall be subject to the responsibilities and liabilities, and entitled to the rights and immunities hereinafter set forth".
"Article VII. Nothing herein contained shall prevent a carrier or a shipper from entering into any agreement, stipulation, reservation or exemption as to the responsibility and liability of the carrier or the ship for the loss or damage to, or in connection with, the custody and care and handling of goods prior to the loading on, and subsequent to the discharge from, the ship on which the goods are carried by sea"
(ii) The responsibility of the Carrier is limited to that part of the Carriage from and during loading onto the vessel up to and including discharge from the vessel and the Carrier shall not be liable for loss of damage to the goods during the period before loading onto and the period after discharging from the vessel, howsoever such loss or damage may arise. Loading and discharge take place when the goods pass the vessel's rail or ramp.
(iii) When the goods are in the custody of the Carrier and/or his subcontractors before loading and after discharge, whether being forwarded to or from the vessel or whether awaiting shipment landed or stored, or put into hulk or craft belonging to the Carrier, or pending transhipment, they are in such custody for the risk and account of the Merchant without any liability of the Carrier".
"The vessel may commence discharging immediately on arrival without notice to the consignee or any other party….on to quay or into shed, warehouse, depot,….vehicle, vessel or craft as the Carrier or his agents may determine. Such discharge shall constitute due delivery of the goods under this Bill of Lading……Whether the vessel's tackles or shore cranes or other means be employed in the course of delivery onto Quay or otherwise, any loss of, of damage to the goods….shall, after the end of the Hague Rules period, be at the sole risk of the consignee in every respect whatsoever…."
"…Notice in writing of loss or damage must be given to the Carrier's Agent at the Port of Discharge or Final Destination, promptly after delivery of the goods and in any case within 3 running days from the date of delivery as defined in Clause 7…"
"Neither the Carrier nor the ship shall in any event be or become liable for any loss or damage to or in connection with the goods in an amount exceeding the limitation allowed under the Hague Rules or the Hague – Visby Rules/SDR limitation or the COGSA limitation, depending on which of these is contractually or compulsorily applicable, per package or unit unless the nature and the value of such goods have been declared by the Merchant before shipment and inserted in the Bill of Lading".
I. Issue Three: If the HVR do apply to the post – discharge period, then, on the true construction of Article IV(5) of the HVR, is MSC entitled to limit its monetary liability for conversion of the cargo during the post – discharge period? If so, to what amount?
"…neither the carrier nor the ship shall in any event be or become liable for any loss or damage to or in connection with the goods in an amount exceeding [the relevant SDRs]…"
apply to limit a shipowner's liability in the case of misdelivery of cargo in the sense used in this judgment.
J. Issue Four: If the HR, alternatively HVR, do not apply to the post – discharge period, then does clause 22 exclude or limit any monetary liability of MSC if it converts the cargo during the post – discharge period?
"….Neither the Carrier nor the ship shall in any event be or become liable for any loss or damage to or in connection with goods in an amount exceeding the limitation allowed under the Hague Rules or the Hague – Visby Rules/SDR limitation or the COGSA limitation, depending on which of these is contractually or compulsorily applicable, per package or unit, unless the nature and the value of such goods have been declared by the Merchant before shipment and inserted in the Bill of Lading….This limitation of liability shall apply to all contractual claims as well as to any claims arising from other causes….."
"…the Carrier shall have no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage to the goods while in its actual or constructive possession before loading or after discharge over ship's rail, or if applicable, on the ship's ramp, however caused".
The Court of Appeal held that this wording could not exclude liability for a misdelivery to someone who had produced a fraudulent bill of lading.
K. Issue Five: If the HR, alternatively HVR, do not apply to the post – discharge period and MSC cannot exclude or limit its monetary liability for conversion of the cargo by virtue of the terms of the bill of lading, then what is the proper measure of damages for conversion of the cargo on the facts of this case? In particular: (a) is
Trafigura
entitled to claim damages on the basis of the cargo at the time of judgment or is that claim limited to the value of the cargo at the time of conversion (ie. 24 or 25 October 2005); (b) is
Trafigura
entitled to recover, in addition to the value of the cargo, any of its "hedging" losses?
(1) In proceedings for wrongful interference against a person who is in possession or in control of the goods relief may be given in accordance with this section, so far as appropriate.
(2) The relief is –
(a) an order for delivery of the goods, and for payment of any consequential damages, or
(b) an order for delivery of the goods, but giving the defendant the alternative of paying damages by reference to the value of the goods, together in either alternative with payment of any consequential damages; or
(c) damages
(3) Subject to rules of court –
(a) relief shall be given under only one of paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) of subsection (2)
…………………….
(5) Where an order is made under subsection (2)(b) the defendant may satisfy the order by returning the goods at any time before execution of judgment, but without prejudice to liability to pay any consequential damages."
"(1) Where damages for wrongful interference are, or would fall to be, assessed on the footing that the claimant is being compensated –
(a) for the whole of his interest in the goods, or
(b) for the whole of his interest in the goods subject to a reduction for contributory negligence
payment of the assessed damages (under all heads) or as the case may be settlement of a claim for damages for the wrong (under all heads) extinguishes the claimant's title to that interest.
……..
(3) It is hereby declared that subsection (1) does not apply where damages are assessed on the footing that the claimant is being compensated for the whole of his interest in the goods, but the damages paid are limited to some lesser amount by virtue of any enactment or rule of law."
Trafigura
would retain title to the cargo as well as obtaining some, albeit limited, damages for its conversion.
Trafigura
asserts. The second sub – question is whether
Trafigura
can recover any "consequential" damages in this case.
"The fundamental object of an award of damages in respect of this tort, as with all wrongs, is to award just compensation for loss suffered. Normally ("prima facie") the measure of damages is the market value of the goods at the time the defendant expropriated them. This is the general rule, because generally this measure represents the amount of the basic loss suffered by the plaintiff owner. He has been dispossessed of his goods by the defendant. Depending on the circumstances some other measure, yielding a higher or lower amount, may be appropriate. The plaintiff may have suffered additional damage consequential on the loss of his goods. Or the goods may have been returned".[67]
Trafigura
has suffered any further loss since the date of conversion of the cargo in October 2005, by virtue either of an increase in the value of the copper in the meantime, or in the form of "hedging losses", then these are all heads of "consequential" loss.[68] Such consequential loss could only be recovered if it was a "reasonably foreseeable" type of loss at the time of the conversion. He submitted that it was not, because MSC could not have foreseen the actions of
Trafigura
and HMC in keeping their sale contract "unpriced", with
Trafigura
maintaining the risk of the goods.
Trafigura.
For much of his career he has been a market shipbroker with specific experience of chartering tonnage in the container trade, but he had not been generally involved in the ship operations side of containers.[69] His evidence was that generally shipowners do not concern themselves with what specific cargoes are in containers unless asked to do so by the shippers or unless it is a dangerous cargo.[70] He had a general knowledge of many trades that shippers engaged in, including metal trading and he knew that involved "hedging", to cope with the fluctuations in prices.[71] He had no detailed knowledge of how hedging was carried on by metal traders.[72] In his 15 years of fixing charters for containers for Canadian Lines in the 1980s/1990s, he had never come across any hedging claims being made against container operators.[73]
Trafigura
and HMC. I am satisfied that although a shipowner in the container trade will know that containers it has agreed to carry on board its ship may well contain metals such as copper, the shipowner will not know the details on which the metal is being bought and sold. I am also satisfied that the shipowner will not know of the mechanism by which the shipper or the consignee of a metal cargo carried in containers might wish to safeguard against increased loss as a result of either delayed delivery or misdelivery against fraudulent bills of lading. There is no evidence on which I could conclude that a shipowner such as MSC would reasonably forsee that if there was misdelivery of a cargo of copper in containers, then, as between shipper and consignee: (i) the contract would be "unpriced"; (ii) the parties might agree to keep the contract "open" and "unpriced" whilst the fate of the goods remained uncertain; or (iii) the shipper would hedge against possible fluctuations in the price of the copper by rolling over forward sales on the LME futures market, with the consequent possibility of "spread" costs and ultimate hedging losses.
Trafigura
has incurred legal costs (other than in relation to this action) in order to safeguard its position in relation to the cargo, those are consequential losses that are foreseeable and are recoverable.
Trafigura
be entitled to recover the value of the goods as at the time of the conversion or at the time of judgment? It is clear from the decision of the Court of Appeal in IBL Ltd v Coussens[81] that, in assessing damages under section 3(2)(b) of TIGA, the court must calculate them by reference to that value of the goods "…as will fairly compensate the plaintiff for its loss if the defendant…" pays the damages and keeps the goods. The appropriate value depends on the facts of the particular case.
Trafigura
(Richards Butler – "RB") and those for MSC (Hill Dickinson – "HD"). Broadly, RB kept HD informed about the hedge positions being open and asked HD for information about the likelihood of release of the cargo to "its rightful owners". HD remained reasonably confident throughout this time, whilst preserving the position of MSC on whether
Trafigura
could recover "hedging costs" from MSC as damages.[82]
Trafigura
and HMC agreed to keep the sale value of the goods "unpriced" and rolled over the "Quotational period" during which the price could be fixed. This was agreed at a time when the copper prices were going up,[83] and HMC had not concluded any contract with a Chinese purchaser because they did not wish to do so until the goods were cleared from customs.[84] At the same time,
Trafigura
has maintained its "hedge" position. Mr Kendrick stated that if
Trafigura
was awarded damages based on the value of the cargo at the time of judgment, then it would immediately close out the hedge position, which would counter any gain made on any increase in the value of the copper cargo since October 2005.
Trafigura
since October 2005, particularly in maintaining the hedge, as unreasonable. In my view it could not do so.
Trafigura
for the loss suffered as a result of MSC's conversion of the cargo is the value as at the date of judgment. There are several reasons for this conclusion.
Trafigura
might recover it. Secondly, the price of copper was going up throughout 2005 and 2006. If
Trafigura
had bought in replacement copper it would have been at a considerably higher price than that paid to Rustenburg. Thirdly, HMC had no resale contract for the copper. If
Trafigura
had bought in replacement cargo, it might have been faced with a position where it had two parcels of physical copper on its hands with no certain buyers, but continuing uncertainty as to the movement in copper prices. The only way
Trafigura
could have guarded against losses in respect of a further cargo if the price had fallen would have been to make a further hedge contract against the second parcel.[85]
Trafigura
not to get in further cargo and to keep open the hedge position on the existing cargo.
Trafigura
will close the hedge position on that cargo at the date of judgment. In its books it will have had to "pay" more to close out that hedge position. Therefore it will not make a windfall profit by being awarded the value of the cargo as at the date of judgment. Fifthly, on the other hand, if MSC has only to pay damages equal to the value of the cargo on conversion in October 2005, it would gain the benefit of any increase in value since that date, because title to the cargo would pass to MSC. That would be particularly unjust to
Trafigura
if MSC is not liable for any "consequential" losses because they are not foreseeable, although
Trafigura's
actions were reasonable.
Trafigura
to keep open the hedge was reasonable. But I would hold that mitigation losses cannot be recovered if the mechanism by which they are incurred (in this case by rolling over a hedge contract) is something that is not foreseeable to the innocent party at the time the contract was concluded or the tort committed.
Trafigura
is entitled to recover as damages the value of the cargo as at the date of judgment. But
Trafigura
cannot recover any consequential losses that were not reasonably foreseeable to MSC at the time of the conversion, in particular the hedging costs. However, the litigation costs in relation to the Chinese proceedings were foreseeable and are recoverable. Those costs are agreed, I understand, at HK$ 678,270.46.
L. Conclusions
(1) On the true construction of the bill of lading contract, in particular clause 1(a), the Hague Visby Rules apply to the bill of lading contract. They do so as a matter of contract, not by "force of law".
(2) On the true construction of the bill of lading, in particular clauses 4, 7 and 22, the Hague Visby Rules do not apply to the period after the cargo had been discharged from the ship but whilst the containers remained in the container terminal to the order of MSC – "the post discharge period".
(3) Issue Three therefore does not arise for decision. However, if I had concluded that the HVR (or the HR) did apply to the post discharge period, I would have concluded that MSC is entitled to rely on Article IV(5) to limit its liability in respect of the misdelivery of the cargo.
(4) On the footing that the HVR do not apply to the post discharge period, then clause 22 of the bill of lading does not exclude or limit any monetary liability of MSC if it converts the cargo during the post – discharge period, as it did in this case.
(5) The proper measure of damages to be recovered by
Trafigura
for MSC's conversion of the cargo (on the assumption that MSC does not deliver up the cargo upon judgment) is the value of the cargo at the date of judgment. No hedging costs or losses are recoverable as either consequential damages or "mitigation losses".
Trafigura's
costs of litigation in the PRC/Hong Kong are recoverable.
Trafigura
for the whole of its interest in the cargo, then
Trafigura's
interest in the cargo is extinguished by virtue of section 5 of TIGA.[87] If there is doubt on this or any other aspects of the proper form of the judgment and any other consequential orders that have to be made as a result of my conclusions, I will hear argument on them.
LIST OF DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ORIGINAL AND FRAUDULENT BILL OF LADING
| Box No./Name | Original Bill of Lading | Fraudulent Bill of Lading |
| Original Bill of Lading | "MSCUDN065539" is stamped | "MSCUDN065539" is typed |
| Number of Original Bol | "THREE/3" | "3/THREE" |
| Box 2 - Consignee | "To order" | "Ningbo Toptrade Imp & Exp.Co., Ltd 11F, Jinmao Building, Area K1ST, Xiaogang, Ningbo, 315803 CHINA Tel: 0086-574-26851000 Fax: 0086-574-26851066/26851099" |
| Box 3 - Notify | "C.Steinweg Warehousing (FE) Pte Limited Room 2404 Hong Kong New World Tower No. 300 Huai Hai Road (M) 20021 Shanghai, China" |
"As per consignee" |
| Box 4 – Space for Carrier's Agent's Endorsements | Empty | "D595482" |
| Box 13 – Cargo description | "18X20' containers S.T.C. 236 bundles copper cathodes" | "Containers S.T.C. 236 bundles copper cathodes" |
| Box 14 – Identify marks of cont or other packages and seal number(s) | "As per attached ryder" | "Container/seal nos: As per attached ryder" |
| Box 14 – Corresp. number of cont or other packages | "18X20'" | Empty |
| Box 14 – Total number of ctrs or other packgs received by the carrier | Empty | "18X20'" |
| Box 15 – Payable at POL | "Durban" | Empty |
| Place and date of issue Durban |
"30 SEP 2005" (stamped) | Empty |
| Shipped on board Date |
"30 SEP 2005" (stamped) | "30/09/2005" (typed) |
| Signed on behalf of the Master | Stamp of "Mediterranean Shipping Company (Pty) Ltd Durban" and signature to the left of the box | Identical stamp of "Mediterranean Shipping Company (Pty) Ltd Durban" although in a slightly different position. Different signature to the bottom right of the stamp |
| Stamp – "shipped on board shipper's load, stowage and count" | Located at bottom right of box 13 | Bottom of box 14 |
| Stamp – "said to contain, the carrier had no means to verify shipper's representation…" | Located in box 15 | Located at bottom right of box 13 |
| Bill of lading number at bottom right of B/L | 9336520 9336521 |
9337014 9337015 |
DEFINITIONS CLAUSE. This contract is between the Merchant and the Master, acting on behalf of the Carrier. Wherever the term "Merchant" appears in this Bill of Lading, (hereafter "B/L") it shall be deemed to include the Shipper, the Consignee, the Holder of the Bill of Lading, the Receiver and the Owner of the Goods (whose liability under this B/L is joint and several). "Carrier" shall mean the vessel and her owner or demise charterer for whom the Master has entered into this contract. The identity of the owners is available from Lloyd's Register of Ships or from Mediterranean Shipping Company (hereinafter "MSC"). MSC shall act as Agents of the owner or demise charterer in arranging the transport covered by this B/L. If, however, it is adjudged for any reason that any other charterer, carrier, manager, operator, agent or MSC is liable as Carrier, then such party shall have the benefit of all the defences, exceptions and limitations applicable to the Carrier herein. "Goods" includes the cargo supplied by the Merchant and includes any container whether or not supplied by or on behalf of the Carrier. "Container" includes any container, trailer, transportable tank, liftvan, pallet, flat or any similar article of transport used to consolidate goods.
……..
1. PARAMOUNT CLAUSE. This B/L shall have effect as follows:
(a) For all trades, except for goods shipped to or from the United States of America, this B/L shall be subject to the 1924 Hague Rules with the express exclusion of Article IX, or, if compulsorily applicable, subject to the 1968 Protocol (Hague-Visby) or any compulsory legislation based on the Hague Rules and/or said Protocols. Where Hague-Visby or similar legislation is compulsorily applicable, the Hague-Visby 1979 Protocol ("SDR" Protocol) shall also apply whether or not mandatory.
The Carrier's tariffs and regulations are incorporated herein as if set forth at length, and copies may be requested in writing from the carrier or any of its agents.
(b) For goods shipped to or from the United States of America, this B/L shall be subject to the US Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1936, and the US Bill of Lading Act 1916 (Pomerene) which shall also apply by contract at all times before loading and after discharge as long as the goods remain in the custody and control of the carrier.
2. LAW AND JURISDICTION
(a) Any claim or dispute arising from the Contract of Carriage evidenced by this B/L shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the High Court of Justice in London, and English law shall be applied
(b) Contrary to (a), any claim or dispute arising from the Contract of Carriage evidenced by this B/L relating to cargo carried to or from the United States of America shall be subject to the sole jurisdiction of the United States, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York and United States law shall be applied
(c) In addition to the above, in case of any dispute relating to freights and other sums payable to the carrier under this contract, the Carrier may, at his option, apply to the court of the port of discharge and/or to the court of the place of final destination (in case of combined transport), provided that such application is not in conflict with the Brussels/Lugano Conventions.
……
7. LOADING, DISCHARGING AND DELIVERY OF THE CARGO. Loading, discharging and delivery of the cargo shall be arranged by the Carrier's Agent unless otherwise agreed. Landing, storing and delivery shall be for Merchant's account. Loading and discharging may commence without previous notice. The Merchant or his assignee shall tender the goods when the vessel is ready to load and as fast as vessel can receive and – but only of required by the Carrier – also outside ordinary working hours notwithstanding any custom of the port. Otherwise the Carrier shall be relieved of any obligation to load such cargo and the vessel may eave the port, without further notice and deadfreight is to be paid. The vessel may commence discharging immediately on arrival without notice to the consignee or any other party, and discharge continuously with or without sorting the goods, or separating them from other goods (whether or not such other goods are in the same ownership) irrespective of whether by day or by night, Sundays and holidays included, any custom of the Port to the contrary notwithstanding, on to quay or into shed, warehouse, depot, hulk, lighter or other premises, vehicle, vessel or craft as the Carrier or his agents may determine. Such discharge shall constitute due delivery of the goods under this Bill of Lading. Demurrage-free time starts. The consignee shall bear any charges or expenses incurred by the Carrier wholly or partly in respect of sorting the goods or separating them from other goods (whether in the same ownership or not) onshore or onboard for any purpose whatsoever, including any charge or expenses in connection with storage onshore or afloat pending such sorting or separation and any apportionment of such charges or expenses by the Carrier among different consignees by any method whatsoever in the discretion of the Carrier shall for the purpose of this clause be final and binding upon the consignee. Delivery over side onto the consignee's lighters is at the vessel's options and, if declared, is subject to the consignee providing sufficient lighters and men to receive the goods as fast as the vessel can deliver, any custom of the Port to the contrary notwithstanding. Whether the vessel's tackles or shore cranes or other means be employed in the course of delivery onto Quay or otherwise, any loss of, or damage to the goods, lighters or injury to personnel employed directly or indirectly by the consignee shall, after the end of the Hague Rules period, be at the sole risk of the consignee in every respect whatsoever. The Carrier, his agents and servants shall not under any circumstances whatever be under any liability for failure to notify the consignee of the arrival of the goods, any custom of the port to contrary notwithstanding. All expenses connected with the loading and discharging up to and from ship's tackle are for the account of the Merchant. If the goods are not taken by the Merchant at the time when the Carrier is entitled to call upon him to take delivery, the Carrier shall be at liberty at the sole risk and expense of the Merchant to put the goods in safe custody. For cargoes of such nature that Port Authorities allow loading and discharge by direct delivery only, the Merchant shall be notified by the agent if so possible. Should the Merchant fail to arrange direct delivery all relevant charges including return freight and handling will be charged to the cargo interests.
…………
9. DEPARTURE AND ARRIVAL DATES, DELAYS AND CONSEQUENTIAL LOSS. The Carrier's liner position lists, sailing lists and other advertisements, are given without any warranty, and no claims shall be acceptable for any change in the dates nor even in the cases of the vessel's non-departure for whatever cause. Carrier shall have the right to change sailing and arrival dates without notice. The Carrier does not undertake that the goods shall arrive at the Pot of Discharge or Place of Delivery at any particular time or to meet any particular market or use and the Carrier shall under no circumstance be liable for direct, indirect or consequential loss or damage due to delay or any other cause whatsoever and howsoever caused.
………
11. DECLARATION OF NATURE, WEIGHT OR MEASUREMENT OF GOODS AND OF CONTENTS OF PACKAGE. If the nature or the value of the cargo has been mis-stated to the Carrier, the Merchant is not liable to any indemnification whatsoever. In all cases incorrect statements shall be considered to have been wilfully misstated. The Merchant is bound to declare exactly the contents of the packages or containers, the weight and the measurement of the goods, and shall be liable for all consequences of damage; which might be caused to vessel or cargo owing to a false declaration, incorrect description, marks or numbers, or incomplete, incorrect or delayed requisite documentation. If on delivery of the goods it is ascertained, either at the time of loading or at any time of unloading that the weight or cubic measurement or value is greater than that declared, or that the goods belong to a higher category than that declared, the Carrier has the right to charge double freight on the ascertained difference, the Merchant to pay the labour and expenses of weighing and measuring the goods entered in this Bill of Lading, if any excess of weight or measurement should be found. This debt is claimable at the same time and in the same manner as the freight, and shall constitute a lien on the goods.
………
15. SPECIAL CARGO. For theft and loss of gold, silver, precious metals, in a manufactured state or not, or specie, ornaments, watches, furs, laces, jewels, precious stones, securities, paper money, documents or other papers of value, silk paintings, porcelain, glassware or other precious articles or variable articles and for damage to precious articles easily damageable, the Carrier is only responsible if the value and nature of the cargo are declared to him before or at any time of reception of the cargo and inserted in the Bill of Lading and provided freight is calculated on the basis of such value. All cargo the value of which exceed 5 pounds Sterling per cubic foot measurement, or per cwt for weight cargo, is classed as previous. Money and all objects of value must be packed double bags with inside seams, or in boxes, both sealed with wax and the seal must be reproduced on the Bill of Lading and shipping orders. In case of such shipments this present B/L is deemed to become automatically not a B/L or document of title in respect of such cargoes, but to take the substance of a non-negotiable receipt, not subject to the Hague Rules, the Hague-Visby Rules the COGSA, which shall not apply.
……….
22. CLAIMS VALUATION, PACKAGE LIMITATION TIME-BAR. The indemnity payable by the Carrier for non-delivery of the cargo in whole or in part is calculated at the option of the Carrier on the basis of the invoice value or on the basis of market values at destination, less duties and expenses saved due to the shortage, except in USA jurisdiction where the sound market value at destination shall be considered. In any event the Carrier's liability shall not exceed the usual sound market value of the goods at the time and place of shipment. However, should the invoice value of the goods be lower than the usual sound market value at the time and place of shipment, the Carrier will only pay the invoice value. For lack of any usual sound market value or invoice value, this provision shall apply to the common value accordingly. Neither the Carrier nor the ship shall in any event be or become liable for any loss or damage to or in connection with goods in an amount exceeding the limitation allowed under the Hague Rules or the Hague-Visby Rules/SDR limitation or the COGSA limitation, depending on which of these is contractually or compulsorily applicable, per package or unit, unless the nature and the value of such goods have been declared by the Merchant before shipment and inserted in the Bill of Lading. However, declaration of value for the purpose of calculation of freight shall not be considered a declaration in the above sense. This limitation of liability shall apply to all contractual claims as well as to any claims arising from other causes. In so far as goods are shipped to or from the United States, the Carrier's liability shall be limited to $500 per package or customary freight unless excess value is inserted on the face hereof and extra charge paid. The words "customary freight unit" shall mean (under COGSA) the unit of weight or measurement customarily used to calculate freight. Where the goods have been packed into sealed containers by or on behalf of the Merchant, it is expressly agreed that each container shall constitute one package for the purpose of application of limitation of the Carrier's liability, since the Carrier cannot verify its contents. If the Merchant has a shortage in goods or numbers shipped under a Bill of Lading, the Carrier shall have the option to deliver as substitute any surplus goods of similar kind or quality. Notice in writing of loss or damage must be given to the Carrier's Agent at the Port of Discharge or Final Destination, promptly after delivery of the goods, and in any case within 3 running days from the date of delivery as defined in Clause 7, and the Carrier to be invited to participate, at his option, in a joint survey. The cargo is otherwise prima facie considered delivered by the Carrier in the same condition as described in the B/L. Claims are to be addressed to the MSC Agent supported by, at least, the following documents: claim narrative identifying clearly the claimant and providing evidence on his title to sue, Original B/L Commercial Invoice of damaged goods, Letter of Subrogation, if any, survey reports. In any event, the Carrier shall be discharged from all liability if suit is not commenced within one year after delivery of the goods or the date that the goods should have been delivered, for claim related to loss or damage during the carriage by sea and nine months for claims related to loss or damage during non-water inland port. Agreed claims will be settled by the Carrier only once with one of the parties that is entitled to sue, i.e. with the Shippers POL or with the Consignees at the POD, but not with both. Settlement of an agreed claim by the Carrier with either of the above discharges the Carrier from all and any liability for the same loss or damage under this B/L.
……….. "
Note 1 It has increased in value since it was sold to Note 2 The UK based shipping agents for Note 3 Standing for: London Metal Exchange. [Back] Note 4 The evidence in the witness statement of Mr Richard Tildesley, Risk Manager for Note 5 There is no dispute that MSC, as shipowner, is the contracting carrier under the bill of lading contract. [Back] Note 6 XX: Day 1/page 55. [Back] Note 7 XX: Day 1/page 56 lines 12 – 15. [Back] Note 8 XX: Day 1/page 58 lines 14 – 18. [Back] Note 9 It is likely that this involved a London based company, officers in Ningbo Toptrade Imp & Exp Co Ltd and others in South Africa and Zimbabwe. I was informed that other cargoes were also involved, but that is irrelevant to this case. [Back] Note 10 Two junior employees were dismissed by MSC South Africa for fraud after a formal disciplinary investigation. [Back] Note 11 The name “Hudong Container Terminal” is based on the Chinese (Mandarin) pronunciation of the terminal’s name. [Back] Note 12 Mr Simon Mao, Vice General Manager, and Ms Fiona Xue, then Traffic Operator for HMC, although now Traffic Operator at Note 13 Witness statement of Fiona Xue, para 15: C1/tab 1/page 4. [Back] Note 14 The witnesses were Mr Richard Tildesley, Note 15 The LME began its “copper contract” for fixing a price of copper 3 months in the future in 1877. At that time most of the production of copper was in Chile, Australia and the Far East. Vessels from those parts took about 3 months to reach the UK, then the largest manufacturer of copper products in the world. See second report of Mr John Shaw, expert in “hedging practice” for the claimants: D1/Tab 4/page 143 paras 8.1 – 8.9. [Back] Note 16 Sometimes there is a discount, depending on the market conditions, ie. availability and demand for the metal at the point of sale. [Back] Note 17 Again, there can be a discount, depending on market conditions, as above. [Back] Note 18 The LME deals in “lots” of 25 tonnes, so this is equal to about 217 lots LME. [Back] Note 19 XX: Day 1/page 108. “Backwardation costs” is confusing because the term “backwardation” is also widely used in forward trading to describe the market where a spot or “cash” price is higher than a 3 month forward price. The opposite is a “contango” market, where the spot or “cash” price is lower than the forward price. [Back] Note 20 XX: Day 1/page 108- 109. [Back] Note 21 B1/page 148: see XX Day 1/page 109. [Back] Note 22 Once the price for the physical sale is fixed, then the “hedging loss” will be any difference between the price for the physical copper and the price fixed for the forward hedge sale which will be finally closed out at the time of the physical sale. [Back] Note 23 XX: Day 1/pages 102 – 104. [Back] Note 24 That is the so – called “Gold value clause) of the HR, which provides: “The monetary value mentioned in these [Hague] Rules are to be taken to be gold value”. [Back] Note 25 Pyrene v Scindia [1954] 2QB 402 at 418 per Devlin J. [Back] Note 26 Mr Kendrick relied in particular on the sentence in clause 7 which provides: “Such discharge [ie. from the vessel] shall constitute due delivery of the goods under this Bill of Lading”. [Back] Note 27 The “gold value clause”: see footnote 24 above. [Back] Note 28 This provides: “Neither the carrier nor the ship shall in any event be or become liable for any loss or damage to or in connection with the goods in an amount exceeding £100 per package or unit…unless the nature and the value of the goods have been declared by the shipper before shipment and inserted in the bill of lading”. [Back] Note 29 The relevant part provides: “Unless the nature and value of the goods have been declared by the shipper before shipment and inserted in the bill of lading, neither the carrier nor the ship shall in any event become liable for any loss or damage to or in connection with the goods in an amount exceeding 666.67 units of account per package or unit….”. [Back] Note 30 The original wording of the HVR was changed by a Protocol in 1979, which provided that the units of account were henceforth to be valued by reference to a “Special Drawing Right” which is itself based on the value of a basket of currencies. In September 2006 an SDR was worth about US$1.5. [Back] Note 31 It is agreed that the HR will apply, if at all, by virtue of the contract provisions in clause 1(a), ie: “For all trades, except for goods shipped to or from the United States of America, this B/L shall be subject to the 1924 Hague Rules with the exclusion of Article IX…” [Back] Note 32 The well – known law was recently affirmed by Lord Hobhouse of Woodborough in Homburg Houtimport BV v Agrosin Ltd (“The STARSIN”) [2004] 1 AC 715 at 770D, para 132. [Back] Note 33 Many cases have pointed out that a bill of lading is not a “negotiable instrument” in the manner of, say, a bill of exchange. But a bill of lading made “to order” is still commonly described as “negotiable”. Lord Hobhouse’s phrase “transferable document of title” is, with respect, more accurate. [Back] Note 34 See the Motis case, referred to in footnote 37 below. [Back] Note 35 The back of the fraudulent bill of lading was not in fact endorsed. It only bore Ningbo’s own stamp: E/tab 12/page 131. [Back] Note 36 See the Motis case, referred to in footnote 37 below at page 216, para 20, per Stuart – Smith LJ. [Back] Note 37 See: Motis Exports Ltd v Dampskibsselskabet AF 1912 Aktieselskab and Aktieselskabet Dampskibsselskabet Svendborg [2000] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 211 at 216 paras 19 and 20 per Stuart – Smith LJ; per Mance LJ at page 217, paras 3 – 5 and 8. Mummery LJ agreed with both judgments. [Back] Note 38 [2002] 2AC 883 at 1084 para 39. [Back] Note 39 Compare The Happy Ranger [2002] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 347 at para 19 per Tuckey LJ; para 47 per Rix LJ. The Paramount Clause in that bill of lading was similar, but not identical. It referred to “…trades where the International Brussels Convention 1924 as amended by the Protocol signed at Brussels on 23 February 1968 – the Hague Visby Rules – apply compulsorily…”. [Back] Note 40 A “Contracting State” is one that signed and ratified the 1968 Protocol, or has since acceded to it, but the phrase also includes Contracting States in respect of the unamended Hague Convention: Merchant Shipping Act 1995, Sch 13, para 45(1) and (7). The list of Contracting States is set out in a statutory instrument: currently the Carriage of Goods by Sea (Parties to Convention) Order IS 1985/443 and the Carriage of Goods by Sea (Parties to Convention) (Amendment) Order IS 2000/1103. South Africa is not amongst them. [Back] Note 41 [2002] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 357. In that case the country of shipment was Italy, a Contracting State. [Back] Note 42 See footnote 40. [Back] Note 43 [1983] AC 565 at 583 [Back] Note 44 [2002] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 357 at para 47. [Back] Note 45 He relied in particular on Pyrene Co Ltd v Scindia Navigation Co Ltd [1954] 2 QB 402 at 417 – 8 per Devlin J; Compania Portorafti Commerciale SA v Ultramar Panama Inc (“The Captain Gregos” No 1) [1990] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 310 at 315 per Bingham LJ; PS Chellaram & Co Ltd v China Ocean Shipping Co (“The Zhi Jiang Kou”) [1991] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 493 (Supreme Ct of New South Wales) particularly per Gleeson CJ at 498 and Kirby P at 515. [Back] Note 46 [2002] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 357 at para 38. [Back] Note 47 [2003] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 1 at para 16
[Back] Note 48 [1980] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 317. [Back] Note 49 This refers to “…the date of delivery as defined in clause 7….”. [Back] Note 50 I therefore agree with the analysis of Carver on Bills of Lading (2nd Ed), para 9 – 131. [Back] Note 51 [[1991] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 493 [Back] Note 52 There was a contractual time – bar, clause 10(2), which provided that “…the Carrier shall be discharged of all liabilities under this bill of lading unless suit is brought and written notice thereof give to the carrier within nine months after delivery of the goods…”. The bill also incorporated the Hague Rules, including Article III(6). [Back] Note 53 BMA Industries v Nigerian Star Line Ltd 786 F.2d 90 (1986) [Back] Note 54 Frans Maas (UK) Ltd v Samsung Electronics (UK) Ltd [2004] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 251. [Back] Note 55 Shaw v the Great Western Railway Company [1894] 2 QB 495. [Back] Note 56 In the Australian case of The “Zhi Jiang Kou”, Carruthers J had held (in the Admiralty Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales) that Article IV(5) of the HR applied to a case of misdelivery by negligence – as he held it to be in that case. The point was not argued on appeal. [Back] Note 57 [2003] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 1 at para 16 – 18 per Longmore LJ [Back] Note 58 [2002] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 357 at para 38 per Tuckey L [Back] Note 59 [1957] AC 149 at page 169 [Back] Note 60 Mr Kendrick relied in this regard on the Motis case [2000] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 211, particularly at page 216, per Stuart – Smith LJ; page 217 per Mance LJ. [Back] Note 61 Para 20. Mummery LJ agreed with that judgment. [Back] Note 62 Paras 20 and 5 of their respective judgments. [Back] Note 63 See Saleslease Ltd v Davis [1999] 1 WLR 1664 (CA), referred to by Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead in the Kuwait Airways case [2002] 2AC 883 at para 100 on page 1097. [Back] Note 64 [2002] 2 AC 883. [Back] Note 65 Paras 77, 78 and 80. [Back] Note 66 Paras 77 and 67. [Back] Note 68 He relied on McGregor on Damages (17th Ed) para 33 – 019 and 33 – 063. [Back] Note 69 Day 2/page 10, lines 17 – 18. [Back] Note 70 Day 2/page 14, lines 9 – 22. [Back] Note 71 Day 2/page 16 line 6 to page 18 line 11. [Back] Note 72 Day 2/page 22 lines 14 – 15; page 23 lines 17 – 21. [Back] Note 73 Day 2/page 11, lines 6 – 11. [Back] Note 74 Day 2/page 42 lines 9 – 24. [Back] Note 75 Day 2/page 48 lines 2 – 10. [Back] Note 76 Day 2/page 41 line 6 to page 42 line 8. [Back] Note 77 Day 2/page 42 lines 17 – 24. [Back] Note 78 Referred to in footnote 63 above. [Back] Note 79 [1991] 2 All ER 133. [Back] Note 80 See particularly para 67. [Back] Note 81 Ibid., particularly at page 139H – I per Neill LJ and page 143J – 144B, per Nicholls LJ. [Back] Note 82 See, eg. RB letter of 27.4.06 to HD and HD response of 2.5.06: Bundle G1/pp 46 – 49; RB to HD on 26.10.06 and HD response on 3.11.06: G1/pp 94 – 5 and 107 – 8. [Back] Note 83 See: Average LME Official Settlement prices for copper from July 2005 to December 2006: Bundle D1/Tab 5 pages 199 - 201. [Back] Note 84 Tildesley statement paras 8, 14 and 17: bundle C1/Tab 2. [Back] Note 85 Expert report of John Shaw (metals trader) for Note 86 I understood Mr Kendrick not to advance a claim for any other hedging costs as “mitigation losses” in the event that the value of the cargo was taken as that at the date of judgment. [Back] Note 87 Mr Parsons did not develop the alternative argument that if MSC is only liable to pay some damages, then it is subrogated (in equity) to the Claimants’ interest in the cargo to the extent of the payment MSC has to make. But I note that the point was taken in MSC’s Outline Argument: para 98. [Back]
Trafigura,
the first claimants, in September 2005. The sale price then, (fixed by reference to the London Metal Exchange official prices) was US$1,331,759. [Back]
Trafigura
were African Cargo Services Ltd (“ACS”). The South African agents of ACS were Windward Shipping (Pty) Ltd. [Back]
Trafigura,
is that the decision to sell the cargo to HMC was taken several weeks before 30 September 2005, but
Trafigura
“did not get round to documenting the sale until later in October. This is a common occurrence as between
Trafigura
and HMC”. I accept that evidence. [Back]
Trafigura
Trading (Shanghai) Co Ltd. [Back]
Trafigura’s
Risk Manager; Mr Simon Everton, a shipbroker, called as an expert by the Claimants; and Mr John Mawson, Master Mariner, who was called as an expert by the Defendants. The two experts were called to give opinions on the extent to which a shipowner engaged in the carriage of containers would, in 2005, have known about hedging practices of metal traders generally; and, in particular in relation to metal cargoes shipped in containers on board container ships. [Back]
Trafigura: Bundle D1/Tab 4, para 9.2. [Back]