![]() |
[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] [DONATE] | |
England and Wales High Court (Commercial Court) Decisions |
||
|
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> England and Wales High Court (Commercial Court) Decisions >> Trafigura Maritime Logistics PTE Ltd v Clearlake Shipping PTE Ltd [2020] EWHC 1073 (Comm) (06 May 2020) URL: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Comm/2020/1073.html Cite as: [2020] EWHC 1073 (Comm) |
||
[New search]
[Context
]
[View without highlighting]
[Printable PDF version]
[Help]
QUEEN'S BENCH DIVISION
COMMERCIAL COURT
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL |
||
B e f o r e :
____________________
TRAFIGURA MARITIME LOGISTICS PTE LTD |
Claimant |
|
| - and - |
||
| CLEARLAKE SHIPPING PTE LTD |
Defendant |
|
| And Between : |
||
| (1) CLEARLAKE CHARTERING USA INC. (2) CLEARLAKE SHIPPING PTE LTD |
Claimants |
|
| - and - |
||
| PETROLEO BRASILEIRO S.A. |
Defendant |
____________________
Trafigura
Robert Thomas QC and Ben Gardner (instructed by Kennedys Law LLP) for Clearlake
Henry Byam-Cook QC (instructed by White & Case LLP) for Petrobras
Hearing date: 30 April 2020
____________________
Crown Copyright ©
"Covid-19 Protocol: This judgment will be handed down by the judge remotely by circulation to the parties' representatives by email and release to BAILII. The date and time for hand-down will be deemed to be 10:30 AM Wednesday 06 May 2020. A copy of the judgment in final form as handed down can be made available after that time, on request by email to the judge's Clerk"
Mr. Justice Teare :
The form of the order
Trafigura
identified no less than 8 points which the parties had not been able to agree and therefore had to be resolved.
More general words
Trafigura
requested that the more general wording be included. Counsel for Clearlake and Petrobras opposed the inclusion of such general words.
Trafigura
for an order which gave "greater precision to the order by identifying the date by which action must be taken and describing the action which must be taken" (see paragraph 10 of my earlier judgment) the retention of the more general words risked confusion, something which was undesirable in an order of the court, especially one which contained a penal notice.
Trafigura
wished to identify with precision what Clearlake and Petrobras were obliged to do the retention of more general words tends to muddy the waters which had just been made clear.
Trafigura
identified two reasons for keeping the more general words in the order.
Trafigura
that Natixis was willing to talk to Petrobras about the wording of the bank guarantee which it would accept. This was contrary to Natixis' position on 22 April; see paragraph 49 of my earlier judgment. Counsel for
Trafigura
therefore suggested that the more general words were required to ensure that Clearlake (and Petrobras) continued their efforts to agree the terms of a bank guarantee acceptable to Natixis, so that security might be provided before the date by which the payment into court was required.
The specific dates
Trafigura
accepted that in the case of Clearlake, a Singaporean company, 8 working days expired on Monday 11 May. Counsel further submitted that in the case of Petrobras, a Brazilian company, 8 working days expired on Friday 8 May. Counsel for Petrobras said that since Petrobras had to effect payment in Singapore it was relevant to take into account that 7 May was a public holiday in Singapore because on that day the Singapore banking and judicial systems would not be functioning. Thus 8 working days expired on 11 May.
The proviso concerning a bank guarantee
Trafigura
or in the form suggested by Petrobras. I consider that it should be in the form suggested by
Trafigura.
That relates to the provision of a bank guarantee, whereas Petrobras' suggestion relates only to agreeing the terms of a bank guarantee, not necessarily its provision.
Staggered obligations
Trafigura
to provide security, the date on which it should provide security should be later than the date on which Petrobras was to provide security so that there would be no unnecessary duplication of expense. If they both had to make payment by 11 May, there would be duplication of expense. If however, Clearlake only had to do so by 15 May then, in the event, as expected, that Petrobras made payment in by 11 May, there would be no need for Clearlake to incur the expenditure of making a payment in.
Trafigura
objected to this. He pointed out that Clearlake owed an obligation to
Trafigura
and that this court had held that such obligation should be satisfied by payment in by 11 May. Clearlake was not entitled to wait and see whether it was necessary for it to make a payment in, especially where the ex parte order had been made as long ago as 24 March.
Trafigura.
Its contractual obligation is not to provide security only if Petrobras does not do so.
Trafigura's
contractual rights. Thus, if the position had been, as submitted by
Trafigura,
that Petrobras' payment in should be made by 8 May, it would have been appropriate and not damaging to
Trafigura's
contractual rights against Clearlake, to order staggered payments by 8 and 11 May. But that is not the position. Both Clearlake and Petrobras must make payment in by 11 May. To permit a later payment in by Clearlake after 11 May would damage
Trafigura's
contractual rights against Clearlake.
Trafigura's
contractual rights against Clearlake in order to enable Clearlake to avoid incurring unnecessary costs. Counsel for Clearlake said that it was because any loss to
Trafigura
caused by the delay in the release of the vessel from arrest resulting from Clearlake having an additional period in which to provide security could (probably) be recovered from Clearlake pursuant to its indemnity. This point has some cogency because it shows that
Trafigura
is (probably) not without remedy. But is it appropriate to subject
Trafigura
to the risk of such loss when, contractually, they should not be exposed to it ?
Trafigura
is correct. Clearlake has entered into a charterparty with
Trafigura.
It has therefore undertaken obligations to
Trafigura.
Performance of those obligations is not dependent on what a sub-charterer does or does not do. Clearlake is not entitled to say that it will only perform its obligations to
Trafigura
if Petrobras does not perform its obligations to Clearlake.
Trafigura
does not expect two payments in to court because it accepts that Clearlake may perform its obligation by "procuring" a payment in to court. Thus if Petrobras makes a payment in
Trafigura
does not expect Clearlake to make a further payment in. However, to relieve Clearlake of the need to incur costs which are likely to prove unnecessary involves rewriting Clearlake's contractual obligation. That would, in my judgment, be wrong in principle. Furthermore, if a choice has to be made between loss to
Trafigura
and loss to Clearlake,
Trafigura
should be protected rather than Clearlake because it is Clearlake which owes the obligation and
Trafigura
which is entitled to the benefit of it.
Making Petrobras party to the action between
Trafigura
and Clearlake for the purposes of costs.
Reservation of the right of
Trafigura
to allege a breach of the injunction
Trafigura
was estopped from alleging breach by reason of my earlier judgment there was no objection to this reservation. I shall therefore ask counsel to agree an appropriate form of words reserving both rights.
Concurrent case management
Trafigura
and Clearlake be copied to Petrobras and (b) stating that where there is an application in the one action, it be heard at the same time as the equivalent application in the other action.
Costs
Trafigura
and Clearlake.
Trafigura
in costs) that
Trafigura
is entitled to its costs up until 15 April 2020. Thereafter, whilst
Trafigura
claims all of its costs, Clearlake says that it should recover no more than 50% of its costs to reflect the issues on which it lost at the inter partes hearing.
Trafigura
obtained a variation to the injunction granted ex parte its primary claim at the inter partes hearing was for an order that Clearlake provide a bank guarantee on the terms acceptable to Natixis. It failed on this both in law (the issue of construction of the indemnity) and on the facts. Moreover, despite being provided with full and detailed evidence as to the steps taken by Clearlake (and Petrobras) to agree the terms of a bank guarantee it continued to accuse Clearlake of "dragging its feet, and otherwise engineering a situation of delay in the hope that it will never need to put up security". I was unable to accept that serious criticism. At the same time it accused Clearlake of a breach of the terms of the injunction whilst not actually seeking a finding to that effect. In those circumstances it was not surprising that Clearlake (and Petrobras) felt it necessary to adduce substantial evidence describing the course of events. Of course a successful claimant is not to be deprived of its costs because it did not win on all points. But
Trafigura
failed on a major part of its case which had generated considerable costs in terms of evidence. Whilst thinking about costs before reading the skeleton arguments, I had formed the provisional view that a reduction of about 50% would be appropriate, fair and just. I was therefore not surprised to read that this was the submission of counsel for Clearlake and Petrobras. By the same token I was surprised to read the submission of counsel for
Trafigura
that, if any reduction was appropriate, a modest reduction of 10-15% was appropriate. I have reconsidered the matter in the light of the written and oral submissions of counsel but I remain of the view that there should be a reduction of 50%.
Trafigura
sought its costs on the indemnity basis. It is well-established that to justify such an order the party's conduct of the case must be out of the norm in such a way as makes it appropriate to order costs on the indemnity basis. It was said that all of
Trafigura's
costs, not just those incurred before 15 April 2020, should be assessed on the indemnity basis. In oral submissions reliance was placed on three matters. First, it was said that Clearlake deliberately did not put up security and that it was guilty of extraordinary behaviour. Reliance was placed on the approach of Colman J. in National Westminster Bank v Rabobank [2008] 1 Lloyd's Rep. 16 where a party commenced proceedings in breach of an anti-suit clause and was ordered to pay costs on the indemnity basis. Second, it was said that Clearlake had not kept
Trafigura
informed of what was going on with regard to the provision of security. Third, it was said to be "relevant to bear in mind" that pursuant to the indemnity in the charterparty
Trafigura
was entitled to be held harmless in respect of any liability, loss, damage or expense of whatsoever nature which it may sustain by reason of giving delivery of the cargo in accordance with the request of Clearlake.
Trafigura
on the decision in National Westminster Bank v Rabobank where Sir Anthony Colman noted, at paragraph 33, what he had said in an earlier case:
"The conduct of a party who deliberately ignores an arbitration or a jurisdiction clause so as to derive from its own breach of contract an unjustifiable procedural advantage is in substance acting in a manner which not only constitutes a breach of contract but which misuses the judicial facilities offered by the English courts or a foreign court. In the ordinary way it can therefore normally be characterised as so serious a departure from ''the norm'' as to require judicial discouragement by more stringent means than an order for costs on the standard basis."
Trafigura
in this court and to prevent
Trafigura
from being put to expense. But indemnity costs are appropriate when the conduct of a party in the proceedings is out of the norm in such a way as to merit indemnity costs. Where the issue of proceedings is itself a breach that test can be satisfied as Sir Anthony Colman explained. But that factor is not to be found in this case. Instead, Clearlake has failed to resist the order sought by
Trafigura
both at the ex parte hearing and at the inter partes hearing. But such failures are not sufficient to merit an order for indemnity costs. A failed defence is not out of the norm.
Trafigura
submitted that it was not kept informed by Clearlake as to what was happening with regard to the provision of security. This was disputed by counsel for Clearlake who said
Trafigura
was kept informed. These conflicting submissions, I assume, mirrored a conflict in the evidence.
Trafigura
was not kept informed of what was happening with regard to security, what is abundantly clear is that very full information was given for the purposes of the inter partes hearing following the serious criticism made of Clearlake by
Trafigura.
Trafigura
is able to do so in the course of the action. The existence of that additional remedy does not assist in enabling
Trafigura
to show that Clearlake's conduct of the proceedings is out of the norm.
Trafigura's
costs will therefore be assessed on the standard basis.
Trafigura
(and Petrobras) wished the court to assess costs summarily there was no time to hear detailed submissions on the costs. The parties had requested 2 hours and the hearing in fact lasted 3 and a half hours. I could not allow the hearing to continue any longer because of my other judicial commitments. There will therefore have to be a detailed assessment.
Trafigura
and (b) that Petrobras pay all of the costs incurred by Clearlake in resisting the application of
Trafigura
and in pursuing Clearlake's claim against Petrobras.
Trafigura
and Clearlake apply equally as between Clearlake and Petrobras. Such costs should be subject to a detailed assessment on the standard basis.
Trafigura
claim are concerned, Clearlake says that because Petrobras refused to provide security on 17 March 2020, Clearlake was bound to resist the application by
Trafigura.
This is not accepted by Petrobras. Petrobras accepts that the consequence of what it said on 17 March was that Clearlake would pursue its claim for security against Petrobras. But whether Clearlake decided to resist the claim for security by
Trafigura
would depend upon the view that Clearlake took of its contractual duties to
Trafigura.
That is a matter for it to assess. For that reason it was submitted that Petrobras' refusal on 17 March to provide security did not cause Clearlake to resist liability to
Trafigura.
Trafigura's
costs pursuant to section 51 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 and Aiden Shipping v Interbulk, The Vimeira [1986] AC 965, alternatively that the costs of Clearlake payable by Petrobras should include the costs payable by Clearlake to
Trafigura.
It was common ground that such an order can only be made where in all the circumstances it is just to make the order.
Trafigura
but also its liability to pay costs to
Trafigura.
I accept that the court has jurisdiction to make such orders if they are just in all the circumstances of the case.
"We deny that Petrobras has any obligation to provide the requested security or that the Warrant of Arrest has been issued as a result of any action by Petrobras. Petrobras has at all times acted in accordance with its contractual obligations towards all parties concerned. We will strongly resist any attempts by Clearlake or any other party to argue to the contrary before the English courts or otherwise."
Trafigura
to put up security and decided not to oppose the application. But if Petrobras had accepted its obligation to provide security on 17 March it is more likely than not that Clearlake would not have incurred costs in defending the application brought by
Trafigura.
Trafigura
sought additional relief on 15 April 2020 it would appear that Clearlake chose to resist the additional relief for its own reasons. It adduced considerable evidence and made its own submissions as to why the additional relief should not be granted. It did not merely say that it passed on up the line the case of Petrobras. It advanced its own case. Had it adopted the passive role of "piggy in the middle" and merely passed on arguments up and down the line its costs would have been much less than they were.
Trafigura's
application and Clearlake's liability to pay the costs of
Trafigura.
That appears to me to be the just order.
Trafigura
action for this purpose.
Trafigura's
costs or Clearlake's own costs in seeking to resist the inter partes order. That appears to me to be the just order.
Payment on account
Trafigura
is concerned its costs claimed against Clearlake total almost £188,000. I was told that some £80,000 related to the period before 15 April. It follows that over £100,000 relates to the period after 15 April. These costs were incurred in relation to an ex parte hearing and an inter partes hearing. Neither hearing was longer than one day. The former was considerably shorter than one day. Clearlake's costs were £110,000 in respect of
Trafigura's
claim and £176,000 in respect of its claim against Petrobras, making a total of some £286,000. Counsel for Petrobras described these levels of costs as "eye-watering". Petrobras' own costs of the inter partes hearing were some £97,000. Although that, as a figure, does not suggest that
Trafigura's
costs of the inter partes were high the court must take a wider view than simply comparing figures. The relief sought by
Trafigura
was not novel but orthodox, having been recognised by recent authority. The evidence required in support was limited. There is, it seems to me, a real prospect that on assessment the reasonable costs of proceedings aimed at securing such relief will be found to have been significantly less than those claimed by
Trafigura
and Clearlake.
Trafigura
submitted that an interim payment of at least £100,000 should be made as against Clearlake. Since
Trafigura's
total costs may well be substantially reduced when assessed on the grounds that they were objectively unreasonable in amount it is probably wise to work on a recovery of about 55%. But it has also to be remembered that
Trafigura
is only entitled to 50% of its costs post 15 April. I will therefore order a payment on account of
Trafigura's
costs in the sum of £72,000 (made up of £45,000 in respect of the period before 15 April and £27,000 in respect of the period after 15 April).
Trafigura's,
perhaps to something below 50%.
Trafigura's
ex parte application and Clearlake's liability to pay costs to
Trafigura
in respect of that application. Winter Scott represented Clearlake until 13 April at a cost of some £28,000. Those costs do not seem excessive and therefore on assessment it is safe to assume that some 65% might be recovered, say £18,000. In respect of Clearlake's liability to
Trafigura
for costs before 15 April I have assessed a payment on account of some £45,000 to be made by Clearlake and so that same figure should be paid by Petrobras to Clearlake. The total figure to be paid on account under this head will therefore be £63,000.
i) By Clearlake to
Trafigura
in the sum of £72,000
ii) By Petrobras to Clearlake in the sum of £60,000
iii) By Petrobras to Clearlake in respect of Clearlake's costs of
Trafigura's ex parte claim against Clearlake and for the latter's liability to pay costs in respect of the same in the sum of £63,000.