![]() |
[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] [DONATE] | |
United Kingdom Employment Appeal Tribunal |
||
|
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> United Kingdom Employment Appeal Tribunal >> Robinson v. Tescom Corporation [2008] UKEAT 0567_07_0303 (3 March 2008) URL: https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKEAT/2008/0567_07_0303.html Cite as: [2008] UKEAT 567_7_303, [2008] UKEAT 0567_07_0303, [2008] IRLR 408 |
||
[New search]
[Context
]
[View without highlighting]
[Printable RTF version]
[Help]
VICTORIA
EMBANKMENT, LONDON EC4Y 0DS| At the Tribunal | |
| On 7 February 2008 | |
Before
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE NELSON
MR J MALLENDER
MS B SWITZER
ROBINSON | APPELLANT |
TESCOM CORPORATION |
RESPONDENT |
Transcript of Proceedings
JUDGMENT
MR JUSTICE HENRIQUES
| For the Appellant | MR RUSSELL ROBINSON(The Appellant in Person) |
| For the Respondent | MR ANDREW ALLEN (of Counsel) Instructed by: Messrs Hammonds Solicitors Rutland House 148 Edmund Street Birmingham West Midlands B3 2JR |
SUMMARY
Contract of Employment – Damages for breach of contract - Implied term /
variation
/ construction of term
Unfair Dismissal – Constructive dismissal
Unfair dismissal, breach of contract: whether unilaterally imposed new terms and conditions of employment from employer were affirmed by the employee agreeing to work under them, but only under protest, treating the contract as extant, but regarding himself as dismissed and able to sue for breach of contract should he not be able to come to an agreement on the new terms and conditions. Dismissal for failing and refusing to abide by the new terms he had agreed to work to: whether conduct sufficient to justify summary dismissal.
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE NELSON
varied
by the Respondent. The Claimant had written a letter of 25 September 2006 agreeing under protest, to work under the terms of the
varied
job description, but had then continued to work to his original terms and conditions and had not resigned. The Respondent seeks to affirm the Employment Tribunal decision, and contends that the Claimant's refusal to abide by the new terms he had agreed to work under, albeit under protest, was, as the Employment Tribunal found, misconduct to which dismissal was a reasonable response.
The Facts.
valves
for the oil and gas industry, the semi conductor industry and the pharmaceutical industry. The Claimant's task was to sell components made by his employer. In October 1997 he was issued with a new job description calling him Territory Manager UK and on 24 January 2003 he had a further job description describing him as Territory Manager with a requirement to sell systems as well as components in the designated sales region. This region was the South East of England covering an area from Great Yarmouth in the North to Slough in the West. The Claimant also worked, though only rarely, on projects outside this area, and travelled round the country accordingly.
view
was that in practice the travel requirements would be no more onerous than before, as although the area was greatly increased, in practice there were no accounts in Wales, Devon or Cornwall nor expectation of such accounts, though there remained a possibility that there would be customer requirements to be satisfied in the whole of that region. The new job description which the Claimant was given described him as Territory Manager, Components and there was no dispute that this covered Area 3 and Area 6. The Claimant asked if a relocation package would be available but was informed by the Respondent that it was not, as it was their
view
that the proposed changes could be achieved from his current location, in Kent.
"Following the account review meeting on 20th September 2006 with yourself, Craig Davies and Iain Johnston I now write to advise you of my response.
I will work under the terms of thevaried
job description, Territory Manager – Components but under protest. I do not accept the terms and I am treating the change as a breach of contract and dismissal from the original contract.
I retain the right to seek damages from my employer for a breach of contract and/or a declaration from the courts that my employer must abide by the original terms of my contract.
I look forward to hearing from you shortly."
Varying
a contract of employment' under the section where such a
variation
was without the agreement of the employee. This leaflet sets out the options available to an employee in such circumstances, including the option chosen by the Claimant, namely to continue working within the
varied
contract under protest, making it clear that the employee does not accept the terms and is treating the change as a breach of contract and dismissal from the original contract.
The Tribunal's findings.
"In the employment context in ourview
it is not practicable for an employee to be able to require an employer to abide by the original terms. By not resigning as a result of the breach of contract, the employee was affirming the continued existence of the contract. In our judgment the Claimant by his letter of 25 September limited any claim that he may have for breach of contract to a claim for damages for that breach. In this situation it is unreasonable to suggest the Claimant can continue in his job but only perform the tasks under his original contract, when the employer requires him to undertake other tasks. The contract that the Claimant was affirming by his letter of 25 September was the contract as amended by the Respondent."
varied
job description, the letter of 16 October 2006 was a reasonable instruction to him to comply with those terms. He made it clear that he did not accept those terms. The Respondent reasonably believed on reasonable grounds that the conduct complained, namely a failure to follow a management instruction had been made out. There was no dispute that the Claimant was refusing to comply with the management instruction to abide by the new terms of contract.
varied
contract and in such circumstances dismissal was within the band of reasonable responses. Accordingly the Tribunal concluded that the Claimant had not been unfairly dismissed, that summary dismissal was not inappropriate and dismissed his claims for both breach of contract and unfair dismissal.
The Submissions.
The Claimant/Claimant's submissions.
varied
terms was, therefore, an unlawful instruction and there were no grounds for dismissal.
varied
terms, but a rejection of the new terms. The Claimant sought to write this letter in accordance with the advice in the ACAS leaflet. He was seeking to carry on working on a without prejudice basis, that is under protest. Ultimately he would sue for breach of contract if no agreement could be reached as to the proper terms upon which he could work. He made it clear at all times that he did not accept the new terms, albeit he said that he would work under them, under protest. As the only contract in existence was the original contract there was no breach until the date of his dismissal on 2 November 2006.
varied
terms, had failed to clarify when one contract ceased to exist and the other came into force, and wrongly found that the instruction that he was to work under the
varied
terms was a lawful instruction when it was not.
variation
of his terms of contract. On examination of the relevant term of the contract however this was not the case and it transpired that the Claimant was submitting that as there was no proper ground for his dismissal he should have been given the three months notice to which he was entitled under the contract.
The Respondent's submissions.
variation
of an employment contract. These are firstly to acquiesce in the
variation,
secondly to resign and claim constructive dismissal, thirdly to refuse to work under the new terms and put the onus upon the employer to take what steps it thinks appropriate including dismissal, and fourthly to 'stand and sue' namely to work under protest and seek damages as set out in Rigby
v
Ferodo [1988] ICR 29 or, if the breach of the contract is so serious as to bring the original contract to an end, bring a claim for unfair dismissal in the Employment Tribunal under the principles in Hogg
v
Dover College [1990] ICR 39.
variations
were not so fundamental as to terminate the old contract and substitute a new one, and in any event such a dismissal after a business reorganisation would have been fair for some other substantial reason. A claim for unfair dismissal in relation to events prior to 25 September 2006 would have been out of time as the ET1 was submitted on 26 January 2007. The claim heard by the Employment Tribunal related to his dismissal on 2 November 2006. The Claimant's letter of 25 October 2006, however, stated not merely that he did not accept the new terms and conditions, but that he would continue working in his old job only, which he did. This he was not entitled to do. It was not open to him to agree to work under protest and then by letter of 25 October 2006 go back on this position and refuse to obey a reasonable instruction. That was not working under protest. He could not force his employers to keep him on his old terms and conditions when he had agreed in his letter of 25 September 2006 to work under the new terms. The Employment Tribunal found that he was agreeing to work to his contract as amended, albeit under protest. That was a reasonable analysis.
v
Dover College. Furthermore, because the Claimant did not resign, as the Employment Tribunal found he could have done, he could not claim for constructive dismissal.
variation
of terms but said that he would work to those new terms, under protest. His employers properly set the date at 16 October 2006 from which he must comply with them, he having said that he would work to them. By then declining to do the
very
thing that he had agreed to do, the Claimant was disobeying an instruction which had been properly given and the Employment Tribunal was right in its conclusion that dismissal in such circumstances was within the band of reasonable responses by the employer.
v
Brillo Manufacturing Co Ltd [1979] IRLR 295 which was referred to by Mr Justice Keith when granting the Claimant leave to appeal, did not assist the Claimant on the facts of this case as in Mr Bashir's case he claimed constructive dismissal, whereas here the Claimant chose not to do so but continued in work having agreed to work the new terms under protest.
Conclusions.
varied
terms. The Claimant sought to follow the ACAS advice leaflet in his 'stand and sue' letter of 25 September 2006. At that time his contract of employment, was, as the Employment Tribunal's found, still extant. It follows that although the Employment Tribunal found that the change brought about by the new terms was significant, it was not so fundamental as to bring the contract to an end. The Employment Tribunal specifically found in paragraph 19, that the Respondent did not bring the contract to an end. The route under Hogg
v
Dover College was not therefore available to the Claimant.
varied
job description, without prejudice and under protest, even though he rejected the new terms, so that if no agreement could be reached between him and his employers he could then sue them for breach. He could in such circumstances, as the Employment Tribunal found, have undergone the trial period, and if his fears had been realised but not addressed, he could have resigned later and referred that resignation back to the original change in contract terms.
varied
job description which he then failed to do.
varied.
varied
job description, but then failed and refused to do. Dismissal in response to the Claimant's refusal was, as the Employment Tribunal found, within the band of reasonable responses.
varied
contract' albeit under protest. Here the Claimant expressly declined to work to the
varied job description he said he would work within.