![]() |
[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] [DONATE] | |
England and Wales High Court (Queen's Bench Division) Decisions |
||
|
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> England and Wales High Court (Queen's Bench Division) Decisions >> OPQ v BJM & Anor [2011] EWHC 1059 (QB) (20 April 2011) URL: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2011/1059.html Cite as: [2011] EMLR 23, [2011] EWHC 1059 (QB) |
||
[New search]
[Context
]
[View without highlighting]
[Printable RTF version]
[Help]
QUEEN'S BENCH DIVISION
SITTING IN PRIVATE
Strand, London, WC2A 2LL |
||
B e f o r e :
____________________
| OPQ | Claimant | |
| - and - | ||
| (1) BJM (2) CJM |
Defendants |
____________________
The Defendants did not appear and were not represented
Hearing date: 6 April 2011
____________________
Crown Copyright ©
Mr Justice Eady :
newspaper group
to sell intimate photographs and other information obtained in circumstances that were clearly private and in respect of which she owed the Claimant a duty of confidence. There was also evidence as to the likely adverse impact of publicity on the health and wellbeing of various members of the Claimant's family.
Newspapers
Ltd but, at that point, someone acting on the First Defendant's behalf contacted the Claimant's solicitor on the evening of 29 January and told him that she would rather do "a deal" with him. It was said that she thought that the Claimant might prefer to pay some money to make the problem go away for good.
News Group Newspapers
Ltd [2011] EWCA Civ 42 at [40].
Newspapers
, my conclusion was that there was no reason why they should prevail over the Article 8 rights of the persons concerned. There was, for example, no public interest in the confidential information; nor would it contribute to "a debate of general interest", in the sense contemplated by the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg in Von Hannover v Germany (2004) 40 EHRR 1.
Newspaper
Publishing Plc [1988] Ch 333 and Att.-Gen. v Times
Newspapers
Ltd [1992] 1 AC 191. Anyone who revealed the confidential information, having knowledge of the court's order, and thereby thwarting its purpose, would be liable to be punished for criminal contempt of court. As Lloyd LJ explained in Att.-Gen. v
Newspaper
Publishing at p.380:
"At common law, if the court makes an order regulating its own procedure and the purpose of the order is plainly to protect the administration of justice, then anyone who subverts that order will be guilty of contempt."
" … I have no conception that it is competent to this Court to hold a man bound by injunction, who is not a party in the cause for the purpose of the cause."
Newspaper
Publishing at 377G, per Lloyd LJ. Indeed, not so long before, in X County Council v A [1985] 1 All ER 53, 55h, Balcombe J (as he then was) expressed the view that the power to grant an injunction other than in personam, and which was expressed to extend contra mundum, was confined to the wardship jurisdiction.
" … it belongs to the King, as parens patriae, having the care of those who are not able to take care of themselves, and is founded on the obvious necessity that the law should place somewhere the care of individuals who cannot take care of themselves, particularly in cases where it is clear that some care should be thrown around them."
Where the court was exercising this jurisdiction, it was not confined by the ordinary constraints of inter partes litigation: see e.g. Scott v Scott [1913] AC 417, 483, where it was characterised by Lord Shaw as being "intra familiam".
Newspaper
Publishing, at pp.388-9, together with Sir John Donaldson MR, that the power to grant a contra mundum injunction was not necessarily restricted to the parens patriae jurisdiction.
new
era": see Venables and Thompson v
News Group Newspapers
Ltd [2001] Fam 430 at [100], per Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss P. It was accepted that remedies had to be fashioned to meet the needs of the particular case in the light of the European Convention. Hence the observations of Lord Phillips MR in Re S (A Child) to which I referred above, at [98]-[99]:
"98. Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss P, sitting in the Family Division, has asserted a jurisdiction to issue an injunction against the world in support of a private law right to confidentiality which is without precedent. In Venables vNews Group Newspapers
Ltd [2001] Fam 430 an application for an injunction was made by the child murderers of James Bulger, who were about to be discharged from prison, having each reached the age of 18. They were to be given false identities and each sought an injunction against the whole world, to continue for his entire lifetime, restraining publication that might lead to the identification of their identities or whereabouts. Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss P granted the injunction. In so doing she was strongly influenced by the fact that the claimants' human rights under Articles 2 and 3 would be threatened if their identities were disclosed. This decision was novel in at least two respects: (1) Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss P recognised a private law right to confidentiality protecting the identities and whereabouts of the two claimants valid against the whole world; (2) the President held that she had jurisdiction to grant an injunction in protection of private law rights against all the world.
99. In X (formerly Bell) v O'Brien [2003] EWHC 1101 (QB), Dame Elizabeth Butler-Sloss P made similar orders protecting the identity and whereabouts of Mary Bell and her daughter. These two decisions are not directly relevant to the present case. They exemplify, however, the manner in which the courts have extended both the scope of confidential information and the use of the injunction to protect this, thereby giving effect to the right to respect for private life conferred by Article 8 of the Convention."
new
methodology in relation to conflicting Convention rights:
i) neither article has as such precedence over the other;
ii) where conflict arises between values under Articles 8 and 10, an "intense focus" is necessary upon the comparative importance of the specific rights being claimed in the individual cases;
iii) the court must take into account the justifications for interfering with or restricting each right;
iv) so too, the proportionality test must be applied to each.
"46. Not every act or measure which adversely affects moral or physical integrity will interfere with the right to respect for private life guaranteed by Art.8. However, the Court's case-law does not exclude that treatment which does not reach the severity of Art.3 treatment may nonetheless breach Art.8 in its private life aspect where there are sufficiently adverse effects on physical and moral integrity.
47. Private life is a broad term not susceptible to exhaustive definition. The Court has already held that elements such as gender identification, name and sexual orientation and sexual life are important elements of the personal sphere protected by Art.8. Mental health must also be regarded as a crucial part of private life associated with the aspect of moral integrity. Article 8 protects a right to identity and personal development, and the right to establish and develop relationships with other human beings and the outside world. The preservation of mental stability is in that context an indispensable precondition to effective enjoyment of the right to respect for private life."
She was accordingly prepared to grant relief to Mary Bell in respect of her Article 8 rights in the light of medical evidence about her mental fragility.
News Group Newspapers
Ltd [2005] EWHC 971 (QB). Evidence was before the court which gave reason to suppose that the claimant's physical wellbeing was at some risk, but there too reference was made to Article 8 and to the analysis in Bensaid:
"Of course the applicant's rights under article 8 of the Convention are also engaged. Those relate to privacy, which is a concept wide enough to include a person's physical and psychological integrity. The preservation of mental stability is recognised as being a necessary precondition for the exercise of rights under Article 8."
Accordingly, the need to protect her mental health was one of the grounds for granting her a contra mundum injunction.
"The foundation of the jurisdiction to restrain publicity in a case such as the present is now derived from Convention rights under the ECHR. This is the simple and direct way to approach such cases."
newspaper groups shortly before Mr Price made his application before me. The Claimant's advisers had been notified that leading counsel was to be instructed on their behalf to resist the order, but once the evidence was disclosed to them the matter was not pursued. I have no idea, therefore, what the grounds of opposition might have been. The only representations I have are in the form of a letter from MGN Ltd querying the jurisdiction (a concern I have endeavoured to answer) and urging that the order should contain a public domain proviso. In those circumstances, I have to carry out the balancing exercise as best I can on the information before me.
"Whilst the right for the public to be informed, a fundamental right in a democratic society that under particular circumstances may even relate to aspects of the private life of public persons, particularly where political personalities are involved … publications whose sole aim is to satisfy the curiosity of a certain public as to the details of the private life of a person, whatever their fame, should not be regarded as contributing to any debate of general interest to society."
A fortiori here, where the Claimant is a private citizen.